It turns out that the actor, who portrayed Claire Dutton in "1883" and is currently playing Sarah Atwood on the present-day series, "Yellowstone," managed to make a case for her recasting by complete accident while attending the prequel's premiere back in 2021.

Are any actors in both Yellowstone and 1883?

Actor James Jordan is a favorite of Sheridan's, having appeared in both Yellowstone, 1883, and his movies Wind River and Those Who Wish Me Dead. In Season 2, he joined Yellowstone as Steve Hendon, a livestock agent who works with Kayce Dutton. This is a regular role and he's returned several times on the show.

How is Claire related to Dutton's?

Claire nee Dutton

Claire (Dawn Olivieri) was the sister to James and Jacob whom we met in 1883. Claire's story just might be the most tragic: She was a widow who also lost six of her children to death. So, when we meet her, she's traveling west with her brother James, bringing along her remaining daughter, Mary Abel.

Who are the same characters in 1883 and 1923?

John Dutton Sr.

John is the only character to cross over between 1883 and 1923. He is portrayed as a child by Audie Rick in 1883 and then as an adult by James Badge Dale in 1923. In 1923, he is married to Emma and they have a son, Jack. It's unclear if John and Emma are also the parents of John Jr.

Who is Elsa Dutton to John Dutton?

Elsa is the sister of John Dutton Senior, but her relationship with Costner's character is more complicated. As John Dutton Junior came into the mix, Elsa is Costner's character's great aunt.

Yellowstone: Margaret & James Dutton's Death Explained!

What happens to Sam after Elsa dies in 1883?

Elsa, who had decided to see her family in Oregon before returning to be with Sam, may be dead, but just as her spirit narrates the series (and the following 1923 series), so it's implied that her spirit reunites with Sam's in the afterlife. Whether this means that Sam too is dead is unknown, but it's not unlikely.

Does Elsa have a baby in 1883?

Indeed, as there are no condoms or any other reliable form of birth control in the frontier, there's a real possibility that Ennis really did impregnate Elsa. Sadly, before 1883 could even drop any clues that Elsa was pregnant, Ennis died in the next episode while Elsa died during the finale.

Who is John Dutton's mother and father?

The son of James and Margaret Dutton, John was only a child when his family founded their homestead in Montana—the land that would ultimately become the Yellowstone Dutton ranch. As an adult, he worked with his uncle, Jacob Dutton, on the family land and had a family of his own; his wife Emma and son Jack.

How are the Duttons in 1923 related to the Duttons in 1883?

Fans of 1883 will remember John Dutton Sr. as a little boy, but by 1923, James and Margaret Dutton's eldest son is all grown up. Through his son, Jack, he's potentially the great-grandfather of Yellowstone's John, but the show hasn't yet confirmed anything on that front yet.

Which character in 1923 is the little boy from 1883?

The oldest son of James and Margaret Dutton, John Dutton I appears in 1883 as a child and in 1923 as an adult, played by James Badge Dale. He worked the Yellowstone land alongside his uncle, Jacob, and had his own family with wife Emma and son Jack.

What happened to Claire on 1883?

Claire (Dawn Olivieri) is James and Jacob's sister, who traveled in 1883 with James's caravan headed West. After her daughter, Mary Abel, was killed outside Fort Worth, Texas, she decided to stay behind and later took her own life. Claire also tragically lost her husband and all her children.

How many sons did Tim McGraw have in 1883?

Patriarch James Dutton appears in 1883 and is portrayed by Tim McGraw. James and his wife Margaret have three children: Elsa, John and Spencer. The patriarch is originally a farmer from Tennessee and a Confederate veteran of the Civil War.

What happened to James Dutton in 1883?

In 1883, James and his wife, Margaret, leave Tennessee with James' sister and niece—both of whom soon die. The Duttons will reach and settle the Yellowstone during this trip, losing their daughter Elsa in the process. James later dies in 1893 after being shot by horse thieves.

How does 1883 connect to 1923?

How Does It Connect to the Franchise? Ford and Mirren will presumably be playing forbears of the Dutton family, but it's not yet clear how they're related to John and his children. In 1883, Tim McGraw played John's great-grandfather James, so it seems likely that 1923 will focus on John's grandparents.

What happened to James Dutton in 1923?

James does return, but it turns out he's been shot, with the first episode of 1923 confirming - via Elsa Dutton's ghostly voiceover narration - that he died of that bullet shortly after. Elsa also reveals that Margaret wrote to Jacob to come help her and her sons at the ranch in the aftermath.

How old is Elsa 1883?

He called her two weeks later and offered her the lead role in the Yellowstone prequel series 1883, playing Elsa Dutton, the 18-year-old daughter who embarks with her parents, James Dutton (Tim McGraw) and Margaret Dutton (Faith Hill), on a treacherous trek across the Great Plains to Montana.

Who was John Dutton's dad?

John second child of James and Margaret Dutton and their eldest son, born in 1878. He was five when they arrived by train in Fort Worth, Texas and set out with the Texas-Oregon Wagon Train.

Is Jack Dutton John Dutton's dad?

As Jack Dutton is the son of John Dutton Sr, it makes him Kevin Costner's character's grandfather. This means if Jack does marry his bride and have a child, the child would be John Dutton's father. Jack's wife-to-be in the series, Liz Strafford, is played by American actress Michelle Randolph.

Is Spencer Dutton the father of John Dutton?

Spencer Dutton is the younger son of James (Tim McGraw) and Margaret Dutton (Faith Hill) from the 1883 series. He is also the younger brother of John Dutton Sr (James Badge Dale). As James Dutton from 1883 was John Dutton's great-grandfather, this makes Spencer one of John's grandfathers.

Does Yellowstone show Elsa's grave?

That Small Detail You Missed in 'Yellowstone' Season 5

Dutton," whose name can't be clearly made out. But upon Monica's (Kelsey Asbille) arrival, we see that the three graves she kneels beside are for James (Tim McGraw), Margaret (Faith Hill), and Elsa Dutton (Isabel May).

Are any of the Dutton family still alive?

John (Kevin Costner) and Evelyn Dutton (Gretchen Mol)

Jamie Dutton (Wes Bentley), Beth Dutton (Kelly Reilly) and Kayce Dutton (Luke Grimes) remain alive and fiery in the fifth season. John's brother Peter, it's also revealed, had died shortly after childbirth.

Who gets Elsa pregnant?

Indeed, as there are no condoms or any other reliable form of birth control in the frontier, there's a real possibility that Ennis really did impregnate Elsa. Sadly, before 1883 could even drop any clues that Elsa was pregnant, Ennis died in the next episode while Elsa died during the finale.

Does Elsa hook up with Sam in 1883?

Later, Elsa and Sam spend the night together which shows this isn't a flash in the pan romance, and that the pair are serious about their relationship. Elsa tells her mother just as much the next morning, but agrees to ride with them to Oregon before eventually returning to Sam.

Why Elsa narrates 1923?

Throughout the episode, Elsa's narration is used to fill in the gaps of what has happened to the Dutton clan in the four decades that have passed since the events of "1883."