Based on skill alone and no force powers, Vader is probably the better duelist, but Windu's Vapaad, allowed him to siphon dark side energy from his opponent into himself and high ten his abilities, allowing him to win against Sidious.
Maybe, but he'd have to be lucky. Duelist-wise, Mace may be superior (especially given his mastery of all seven forms and given Vader's slower movements after his suit). However, Vader is far superior in force power.
Only three Jedi/Sith in Windu's lifetime ever surpassed him, (Darth Sidious, Master Yoda, and Anakin Skywalker) and all three just so happened to be candidates for “most powerful Force-User in the Republics' 25,000 year history” at various times. Windu was considered to be every bit as skilled as Count Dooku.
Once he became Darth Vader, Anakin had long become superior to Dooku and Mace Windu. He exceeded their power while still living as Anakin Skywalker, and greatly exceeded their power later in life, both in the force and in lightsaber combat.
As Darth Vader, he was one of the strongest beings in the entire galaxy. But even then, he was never able to surpass his master, Darth Sidious. A Sith Apprentice can only become the master when they murder the one who trained them.
So if Mace Windu fought Vader in a lightsaber battle, Windu would most likely win, but in terms of dueling skill alone, Vader takes the cake. George Lucus said that Darth Vader was the best duellist to ever live.
Yep. Darth Maul didn't really say or show straight up that he "feared" Darth Vader, but he openly stated his belief that he could not defeat Darth Vader without the help of the Jedi, therefore on his own.
Windu has created and fully mastered Vaapad, a variant of Form VII. Yoda mastered the original variant known as Juyo. Both of them were able to fight with Palpatine on equal ground, matching him blow for blow. It is stated that Yoda beat Mace in a sparring match.
Mace Windu vs Darth Maul | Fandom. Mace windu clear winner 9/10 times. His use of vapad would make the fight play out similair to windu vs palpatine. He would use the seething rage pouring out of maul against him, and as mauls force power was so much weaker than windu's it would be an undisputed win for windu.
In the long run, both Windu and Yoda outdid Palpatine. His belief that Mace Windu was more powerful than Yoda was of little account. After all, Windu himself knew Yoda was superior, and he had no qualms about admitting it.
If Mace Windu never used Vaapad on Darth Sidious, could Windu have beaten Sidious? Honestly, no. Vaapad, the seventh from of lightsaber combat, is a dangerous fighting style that used both the light side of the Force combined with the dark side. It gave Mace the upper hand in many scenarios.
Yes. This is going to be unpopular, however, it's fairly clear from various sources, including Lucas himself, that Palpatine did let Mace Windu win. Lucas himself noted during hos commentary on the film But this part where he, he pretends to lose his power and be weak was something I added later.
Most of the prequel-era Jedi never got to interact with Luke Skywalker, including Mace Windu. However, in a hypothetical crossover between Luke and the prequels' Jedi Order, Mace Windu would be a strong candidate to defeat Luke Skywalker.
In Star Wars Legends and Canon, Galen Marek (Starkiller) is the only Jedi (other than Obi-Wan Kenobi) to put a beat down on Darth Vader/Anakin Skywalker. Galen was secretly trained as a Sith Lord apprentice to Vader, but returned to the light side and the Jedi.
Yoda's presence on Dagobah was likely hidden due to his mastery of Force Stealth and the planet's connection to the Force. Yoda, with his enhanced Force abilities and potential home-field advantage, would have had the upper hand against Darth Vader if they engaged in a lightsaber duel.
With her combined lightsaber skills and her unfathomably powerful Force abilities, Rey would surely be able to put up a fight in a confrontation with Darth Vader. With enough training, Rey would even be able to overpower him.
That notwithstanding, Master Windu was also one of the best. If the two spared as Jedi, Dooku would probably win the match because he was the better all-around duelist.
Though seemingly unbeatable, General Grievous famously met his end on Utapau, thanks to Obi-Wan, and was previously defeated by Mace Windu during the Battle of Coruscant, but Windu had also bested Grievous one other time, as shown in issue 5 of Star Wars: Obsession, by Haden Blackman and Brian Ching.
The duel. Darth Vader defeats Darth Maul. The two Sith Lords engaged in a lightsaber duel, going through the volcano and onto a bridge situated over a river of lava, which collapsed, though they both survived and continued their battle.
Fett would take a beat down. Mace Windu would win very easily. Boba Fett may be a badass, but that is within the category of non-Force users. He can chase down and take down smugglers and criminal scum.
Like all in the Order, the young Korun boy was taught by Grand Master Yoda when he was a learner, and eventually went on to become a Padawan to another Jedi. At one point during his apprenticeship, Windu trained under Master T'ra Saa.
Mace seemed to defeat Sidious and raised his lightsaber to strike down the Sith Lord, but a desperate Anakin ignited his own weapon and severed Mace's forearm. Sidious then blasted Mace with Force lightning, sending the great Jedi champion plummeting to his death.
