(I think part of the reason Snape is so very unhinged towards Sirius and Remus in PoA is that he believes, like everyone else, that Sirius was the Secret-Keeper and that Sirius therefore betrayed Lily to her death - and that Remus is helping him.

Did Snape really think Sirius was guilty?

No, he didn't know. That's why Rowling specified that in Vold War One the Death Eaters were organised into cells, with each only knowing the identity of a few of the others. So Snape didn't know Pettigrew was a Death Eater, and he didn't know that Sirius wasn't one.

Why does Snape hate Sirius?

Because just like everyone else Severus was convinced that Sirius was a fanatical and mass murdering death eater who betrayed James and Lily to their deaths. Imo, Snape hates Sirius, because he trusted him and Sirius broke that trust.

Who did Snape hate more, James or Sirius?

There is always an implicit ire directed at James the most, because as we see in SWM and as Snape's dialogue pretty much everywhere implies, he was the one who lead the bullying. Although he hates Sirius and Lupin quite a bit too.

Why did Snape want revenge on Sirius?

Snape believed that Sirius betrayed Lily and had her killed. Mixed with some of his own part that he played he hated Sirius more than anything.

Why Dumbledore Said 'After All This Time?' to Snape - Harry Potter Explained

Did Sirius apologize to Snape?

No, James and Sirius did not apologize to Snape for their bullying, but that doesn't mean they never felt regretful of their actions. They had seven years of mutual antagonism, and they loathed each other to the bitter end.

Did Dumbledore think Sirius was innocent?

Dumbledore's lack of belief that Sirius is innocent is also suspect. Sirius was a member of the Order of the Phoenix which fought against Death Eaters, but Sirius also was as close to James as a brother, the Potters even took him in when he ran away from home.

Did Snape regret calling Lily a mudblood?

He Called Lily A Mudblood

Even though Snape repeatedly tried to apologize for his mistake afterward, it became clear that it was yet another incident that had done irreparable damage to their friendship.

Did James Potter really bully Snape?

Yes, he did bully Snape but so did the other marauders like Sirius - Remus wasn't really any better - did he stop James from bullying Snape? Did Peter? And yet people still call Remus a good man (which I believe fully :)) But James Potter died to protect his family. He gave Sirius a home when he needed it.

Why did Dumbledore help Snape but not Sirius?

After all, Severus Snape was a proud man. Sirius Black was also a proud man. He was also assumed guilty and Dumbledore had no reason to assume differently, and no reason to help him as Sirius hadn't repented, showed remorse, or asked for any help from any Order members.

Why was James Potter so mean to Snape?

He Justified His Bullying As His Attraction To Lily

Harry's visit to Snape's worst memory in the Pensieve confirmed that James targeted Snape more because he was friends with Lily, something that made him jealous.

Why did Azkaban not affect Sirius?

The prolonged misery of being exposed to dementors kept the prisoners locked within their own minds, so Sirius lost the ability to transform. However, Sirius explained that the knowledge of his innocence kept him sane in a way most of Azkaban's prisoners were not.

Could Snape beat Sirius?

Snape, easily. Back when they were students, they may may have been more or less equal as duelists, with Snape perhaps being the better one by sheer virtue of having to deal with 4 on 1 odds against the Marauders.

Did the Weasley know Sirius was innocent?

In the fourth book, Mrs. Weasley sees Sirius transform from his Animagus form and Ron tells her “it's okay.” Mr. Weasley, Mrs. Weasley, and Sirius are in the Order together in the fifth book, so we can assume that the other Order members know Sirius is innocent.

Did Remus always know Sirius was innocent?

Until the climax of Prisoner of Azkaban, Lupin believed Sirius Black was guilty of murdering 12 Muggles, betraying Lily and James Potter, and killing Peter Pettigrew. He eventually discovered the truth — that Sirius was innocent, and the very much alive Peter was the traitor.

Did Sirius Black really betrayed Harry's parents?

Sirius Black was believed to be the Potters' Secret Keeper, but he secretly switched with Peter Pettigrew, who turned out to be a mole. James' bullying behavior at Hogwarts and his relationship with Peter contributed to the tragic events that led to the Potters' deaths and the rise of Harry Potter's story.

Why did Lily choose James over Snape?

Originally Answered: In the Harry Potter series, why didn't Lily marry Snape? The simple answer: She didn't love him. The more complicated answer: He proved again and again that he wasn't willing to listen to Lily, respect her or her views, or love her in a healthy way.

Did Lily ever love Snape?

Lily Only Ever Saw Snape As A Friend

As much as people romanticize Snape's infatuation with Lily, the fact she did not love him back romantically is ignored. The fact Snape and Lily were only friends, and she only saw it as such, reveals a lot about his refusal to respect her boundaries.

Did Lily know Snape loved her?

Snape wasn't unrequitted, but he merely loved Lily in a puppy, childish way just the same way she loved him. He didn't mature his feelings until very late, as an adult, when she was already out of grasp. Remember what Rowling said when she was asked if Lily ever reciprocated Snape's feelings.

Did Lily ever forgive Snape?

She missed Snape, but she knew she could never forgive him. Snape never stopped trying to make amends. But Lily remained steadfast. She could not, would not, forgive him.

What did Lily call Snape?

Lily called Severus “Snivellus “ because only a Snivellus would call his best friend a filthy little mudblood. Severus became Snivellus when he was a bigoted bully, attacking a friend whom actually stopped his enemies from bullying him.

What did Dumbledore mean when he asked Snape Lily?

Then, Dumbledore asked, "After all this time?" I think he was asking whether Snape had this Patronus for the 17 years Lily was dead, whether it changed, whether his loyalty to Lily ever wavered. "Always," Snape responded. Snape has cared for Lily since knowing her.

Why did Dumbledore give Hermione a time turner?

Hermione Granger received one from Professor McGonagall in 1993, so that she could attend more classes in her third year than time would allow.

How did fudge know Sirius was innocent?

For instance, he was able to admit to the Muggle Prime Minister, with somewhat humbleness, that starting a ruthless manhunt for Sirius Black may have been aimless since he was in fact innocent all along, which Fudge realised when he learned that Black was killed by his own cousin in the Battle of the Department of ...

Why did they think Sirius was bad?

Sirius Black is introduced in the third Harry Potter installment as the Prisoner of Azkaban, a dark and menacing figure feared by the Wizarding World almost as much as Voldemort himself. Everyone believes he's a mass murderer who betrayed Harry Potter's parents to the Dark Side.