The Prophecy states that the one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord would be born at the end of July to parents who had defied Voldemort three times. Both Harry and Neville Longbottom fit this description, but Voldemort chose to apply the Prophecy to Harry.

What if the prophecy was about Neville?

A Chosen One Neville would have made Voldemort successful in his goals. Snape would not have been driven by love to tell Dumbledore who Voldemort had chosen, or that Voldemort even knew of the prophecy, which means Dumbledore would not have known to put a Fidelius charm on the Longbottoms' house.

What was the point of the prophecy in Order of the Phoenix?

By the end of the Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix movie, Harry had learned the basics of what the prophecy contained. He learned that, according to Trelawney's prediction, he was the Chosen One destined to take the Dark Lord down. However, aside from this, the prophecy seemed unimportant to the movie's plot.

What is the theory of Neville Longbottom?

5) Neville was actually the chosen one

This theory proposes that it was Neville who was the Chosen One and not Harry Potter after all. Based on the prophecy, it would make sense as Neville's birthday also falls towards the end of July and his parents were cruelly tortured to insanity.

What was the full prophecy in Harry Potter?

The prophecy told by Sybill Trelawney tied Harry and Voldemort together and predicted that one must die at the other's hand for “neither can live while the other survives.” Once acted upon by Voldemort, the prophecy doomed Harry and Voldemort to a life of battling each other which concluded in the Battle of Hogwarts.

What is Neville Longbottom’s Patronus? | Harry Potter Theory

Is Neville the chosen one?

While most fans agree that Harry is the unrefuted Chosen One, the final Deathly Hallows film (in particular) sways heavily toward highlighting a heroic Neville, revitalizing the debate regarding which boy is better suited for the iconic title. "The one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord approaches ...

Why did Voldemort choose Harry over Neville?

Initially, Voldemort twisted Harry into the position by first looking at his lineage. Tom Riddle and Harry Potter were both half-bloods, which meant Harry was more like him than the pureblooded Neville. From there, Voldemort focused specifically on the Potters, who had defied him to no end.

Is Neville Longbottom pure blood?

Neville is a pure-blood wizard born to Frank and Alice Longbottom, who were prominent Aurors and also members of the Order of the Phoenix during the first war against Lord Voldemort.

Why didn't Neville marry Luna?

“He wants to have a stable job at Hogwarts. And Luna is a bit too kooky and out there for him and she wants to go out and travel the world. And their lifestyles just wouldn't mix.

Did Neville marry Luna?

Does Luna and Neville get married? No, they do not. Neville married Hannah Abbott, and Luna married Rolf Scamander, the grandson of Newt/Newton Scamander.

Why was the prophecy either Harry or Neville?

In the books it is made explicitly clear that Neville or Harry could be the chosen one as both were males born on the last couple of days of July in 1980, and both parents were a threat to Voldemort, and both parents were taken out by Voldemort/his supporters.

Why was the prophecy about Harry or Neville?

The only reason why it was Harry is that Voldemort thought he was the child the prophecy was talking about. By targeting him and trying to kill him, Voldemort marked him as his equal, while Neville got to live his life without that burden (though that doesn't mean he had an easy life).

Was Umbridge a death eater?

Harry describes Umbridge to Sirius Black, saying that she's vile enough to be a Death Eater, despite not being one. Umbridge is also depicted to be a prejudiced person, despising half-breeds and Muggle-born witches and wizards to the point of firing Hagrid due to his half-giant birth status.

Was the prophecy about Neville and not Harry?

The Prophecy states that the one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord would be born at the end of July to parents who had defied Voldemort three times. Both Harry and Neville Longbottom fit this description, but Voldemort chose to apply the Prophecy to Harry.

Did Voldemort mark Neville as his equal?

Neville isn't the Chosen One because Voldemort 'chose' Harry, by “marking him as his equal”. First of all, Voldemort didn't hear the whole prophecy. He heard only till the part that describes the time of birth, and the parents of the chosen one. He did not hear the part of the dark lord marking him as his equal.

Why did Voldemort choose Draco?

Voldemort intended Draco to die in the attempt to kill Dumbledore so that Lucius would be punished for his failure to retrieve the prophecy from the Ministry of Magic.

Does Neville love Luna in the books?

Neville ended up marrying Hannah Abbott

Even though the film version of Neville seemed to have a crush on Luna, J.K. Rowling revealed that it was Hannah Abbott (a Hufflepuff from his year at school) that he ended up marrying.

Did Neville ever tell Luna he loves her?

Question: Neville and Luna? So in the books, Neville and Luna were never a thing, but in the movies, Neville confesses that he likes her ("Luna?" "Yeah! I'm mad for her! Figured now was as good a time as ever to tell her, since we'll probably be dead by morning!" *something like that*).

Are Luna and Neville canon?

While it is indeed canon that Neville and Luna would get together simply because Jo said it was possible, it is also canon they ended up with different spouses.

Is Dumbledore a pureblood?

An interesting fact of note is that despite the ideals that pure-bloods are inherently more powerful wizards, some of the most powerful or particularly adept wizards and witches in the series are in fact either half-blood (such as Lord Voldemort, Albus Dumbledore, Minerva McGonagall, Severus Snape and Harry Potter) or ...

Why isn't Harry a pureblood?

Harry is a half-blood because his mother was born to a Muggle family while his father was born to a Wizarding couple. It doesn't matter what social standing someone manages to achieve or inherit to those who made the definition. Tonks is a halfblood despite being descended from the Black family on her mother's side.

Are the Weasleys still pureblood?

Identified pure-blood families include the Blacks, Crouches, Fudges, Gaunts (though this line died out before the beginning of Philosopher's Stone), Lestranges, Longbottoms, Malfoys and Weasleys (but the most recent generation has had half-blood members).

Who was the real chosen one in Harry Potter?

The chosen one | Fandom. Cuz the prophecy was not just based on date of birth, there were other conditions too which both Harry and Neville fulfilled but except that Voldy marked Harry as his equal by giving him the scar rather than Neville and so Harry became the chosen one.

Who killed Voldemort Neville?

In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2, Neville is actually the person who destroys Voldemort's last Horcrux in Nagini, rendering him mortal, meaning that he and Harry truly delivered the final blows to Voldemort.

How did Snape hear the prophecy?

Severus Snape, who at the time was working for Voldemort, was caught eavesdropping on Trelawney and Dumbledore by the owner of the Hog's Head and was subsequently thrown out of the pub. Snape then returned to Voldemort to tell him what he had heard.