What really confuses viewers about who killed Katie in Mystic River is Dave's unexpected confession: Jimmy says he will let Dave go free to face the law if he admits he killed Katie. Dave does so, and Jimmy mercilessly slits Dave's throat.

Why did Jimmy kill Dave in Mystic River?

He beat to death a child molester whom he found with a child prostitute. Jimmy does not believe Dave and pulls out a knife. He promises to let Dave live if he confesses to Katie's murder. However, when Dave admits to killing Katie, Jimmy kills him and disposes of his body in the adjacent Mystic River.

Was Dave innocent in Mystic River?

A Childish Prank Results In The Murder

Although Jimmy was pretty much convinced that Dave killed his daughter in Mystic River, the real culprits were "Silent Ray" Harris and John O'Shea, who killed Katie after a prank gone wrong.

Was Dave molested in Mystic River?

In 1975, when he was playing hockey with his friends Jimmy and Sean, Dave was tricked and kidnapped by two child molesters. They held him in captivity in the woods and raped him for four days. Dave escaped, but he never truly returned to society.

What is the point of the movie Mystic River?

The film, based upon the book by Dennis Lehane, explores the impact that the abduction and rape of a young boy by two pedophiles has on him and his two friends some twenty-five years later.

Mystic River (7/10) Movie CLIP - Admit What You Did (2003) HD

Why did Dave confess to killing Katie?

When Dave confesses Katie's murder, he's actually confessing that he always wondered how things would have turned out had Jimmy or Sean gotten in that car years ago, not him. Mystic River's Dave is guilty of resenting the two for living the life he could've lived.

Why did Lauren leave Sean in Mystic River?

Lehane writes that Sean's wife “Lauren” was having an affair with another man, and when she left him, Sean did not know if the baby she was carrying was his or not. Their marriage had broken down because he was overly preoccupied with his job.

What did the men do to Dave in Mystic River?

As children, while Jimmy and Sean stood on an unremarkable patch of Bostonian blacktop, two men who claimed to be cops took Dave away. Unbeknownst to the boys, they weren't policemen; they were child molesters. Four days later Dave escaped and authorities seized the men.

What happened to Dave at the beginning of Mystic River?

The novel's plot revolves around three boys who grow up as friends in Boston — Dave Boyle, Sean Devine, and Jimmy Marcus. At the beginning of the story, Dave is abducted by child molesters while he, Sean, and Jimmy are horsing around on a neighborhood street.

Did Dave get mugged in Mystic River?

Inciting Event: Dave comes home at 3AM with a gash on his chest. He tells his wife he was mugged and that he thinks he may have accidentally killed the mugger—but his facts don't quite line up. Shortly after, Jimmy's daughter Katie's abandoned car is found with the door ajar and the seat bloodstained.

Is there a sequel to the Mystic River movie?

Before a book signing in Toronto, Lehane chatted about Since We Fell's twisted love story, adapting Stephen King and why there will never be a sequel to Mystic River. There's a criminal element to Since We Fell, but it's really the story of a marriage – which is something new for you.

Was Mystic River based on a true story?

“Mystic River” is based on a novel and while it's complete fiction, the story seems very believable. Boston is the perfect setting. Both Penn and Robbins won Oscars for their performances.

Who is Dave's wife in Mystic River?

Dave's wife, Celeste (Marcia Gay Harden), overwhelmed with fear and guilt, tells Jimmy that the night Katie died Dave came home covered in blood.

Who won the Oscars for Mystic River?

Oscars flashback: Why Sean Penn won Best Actor for Mystic River - GoldDerby.

Which boy was taken in Mystic River?

Three childhood friends — Jimmy Markum (Sean Penn), Sean Devine (Kevin Bacon) and Dave Boyle (Tim Robbins) — drifted away from each other after Dave was abducted and molested as a child. Dave escaped, but this tragic event greatly affected the boys and impacted how each of them grew up.

Who is Silent Ray in Mystic River?

Spencer Treat Clark: Silent Ray Harris

Be the first to contribute! Add a photo or add a quote.

Where is Mystic River filmed?

Clint Eastwood's masterpiece drama mystery, Mystic River (2003), took in most of Boston's neighborhoods. The movie's opening kidnapping scene was shot on Condor Street in East Boston, and the face-off between Tim Robbins' and Sean Penn's characters was shot at a made-up bar on Border Street.

Is Mystic River worth watching?

Eastwood's expert direction and wonderful performances from the three leads make MYSTIC RIVER a drama worth watching.

Who were the Savage Brothers in Mystic River?

As fate (or Fate) would have it, the investigating detective is Sean: He and his partner, Whitey (Laurence Fishburne in a triumphant piece of colorblind casting), have to keep the volatile Jimmy and a pair of local hoods known as the Savage brothers (Kevin Chapman and Adam Nelson) from finding the killer before the ...

Who are the savage brothers in Mystic River?

The Savage Brothers are the local thugs that help Jimmy scour the neighborhood for the killer, as the locals are distrustful of the police and talk more freely to their own kind. On the same night as the murder, it was Dave's (Tim Robbins) hard luck to be the last person to see Katie alive at the local bar.

Who was Katie's boyfriend in Mystic River?

Even the Savage brothers are forced to admit to Jimmy Markum that Sean and Whitey are doing their jobs well in covering all the bases. They check out the Harris home and interview Brendan about his relationship with Katie. It is obvious to both detectives that Brendan truly loved Katie and is innocent of her murder.

How old is Katie in Mystic River?

Boyle, Jimmy Marcus and Sean Devine grow apart as the years pass, but a quarter century later they are thrust back together when Marcus's 19-year-old daughter, Katie, is murdered in a local park.

Do Katie and Dave end up together?

Hit-Girl goes on an insane killing spree, taking out the mob boss, his goons, and a whole mess of crooked cops. They both escape. The good guys win. Dave and Katie end up being a serious couple, Dave gives up being Kick-Ass for good and grows up to become a cop.

Why did Katie and Dave break up?

Dave's girlfriend Katie Deauxma breaks off their relationship due to her mistakenly believing Dave to have been cheating on her with Mindy.

Is Mystic River set in Boston?

The tragic murder of a 19-year-old girl reunites three childhood friends still living in Boston--the victim's gangster father, a detective, and the disturbed man they both suspect of killing...