Without BFR & BFD, neither character is hurting the other. Superman can't do anything to Juggernaut, and while Juggernaut could "hurt" Superman, he won't be able to catch/tag him enough to do much.
In DC Versus Marvel #1, Superman beat the Juggernaut with a single punch. The question, then, isn't really who would win in a fight - with his versatile powerset and formidable solar-powered strength, Superman is the default victor - but rather if Superman could physically stop the Juggernaut mid-stride.
As fans know, Juggernaut's biggest weakness is that he's highly vulnerable to psychic attacks across the board, a tactic made possible only if his helmet is removed first.
Who in DC can beat Juggernaut? Eclipso outclasses Juggernaut. Sure, Juggernaut is strong, but Eclipso is not only strong and invulnerable, but can project blasts of energy, has vast telepathic might, can manipulate matter, and do all kinds of other things.
The Juggernaut, despite his incredible strength, has been defeated by surprising heroes like Professor Xavier, Cyclops, Banshee, and Lost. These heroes used their unique abilities, whether it be telepathy, strategic thinking, sonic blasts, or reality manipulation, to overcome the seemingly unstoppable villain.
When Mr. Sinister looks into his five-year plan, it reveals Juggernaut is used as a weapon to murder Thanos, as his powers are boosted, turning him into a being strong enough to kill the Mad Titan in one of the most brutal ways imaginable.
This feat means that even though Juggernaut's magic makes him unstoppable, Hulk has the overwhelming power to thwart Juggernaut's supernatural rules. But he still can't force him to surrender, or destroy him as he would need to for a true 'win.
Despite the fact that Galactus is a cosmic being older than the universe who regularly consumes entire planets, the earthbound Juggernaut shockingly proves to be more powerful than him–and one stunning side-by-side comparison confirms it.
Fortunately, as long as he has Mjolnir, he won't need to. When the two faced each other in the past, Thor beat Juggernaut by generating an anti-magic whirlwind with his hammer, effectively removing Cain's magical invulnerability.
While Juggernaut is usually one of the strongest characters in the Marvel Universe, Superman makes short work of him here with his legendary super-strength. However, Marko's abilities should transcend the Kryptonian's physical prowess.
Despite the fact that no physical challenge is enough to stop the Juggernaut, and telepathic attacks only prove to temporarily slow him down, it seems he does have a weakness after all, as X-Men confirms a brain aneurysm is the one thing that can actually kill the Juggernaut.
However, for some reason, Wolverine has never been able to defeat Juggernaut on his own. That doesn't mean he wouldn't try. Wolverine even tried to fight Juggernaut when all he had was bone claws. However, Wolverine has never been able to beat this unstoppable foe.
Even in the few times he's faced Superman, the green monster has lost. It's no fault of the Hulk's, but Superman is called Superman for a reason. Unless he had kryptonite or a magic-user by his side, Hulk would usually fall to the DC Hero - although, he'd put up a hell of a fight. Superman wins.
Superman has proven to be quite vulnerable to telepaths over the years. While the individual members of the X-Men wouldn't stand a chance against Superman, the team's telepaths would give them a huge edge over the Man of Steel, enhancing their teamwork and shutting him down before he could do too much damage.
3 Magneto. Much like other mutants who are not physically strong but are capable of great physical feats, the Omega-level Master of Magnetism could defeat the Juggernaut in any number of ways.
He is somewhat the same in the comics, so if Deadpool ever faced Thor, the god of thunder would have the winning edge. It's true that Deadpool managed to terminate Thor using Pym Particles in a non-canon comic by enlarging Mjolnir. But MCU Thor never needed Mjolnir in the first place.
So while Juggernaut is much more powerful, and would normally be able to win in a fight, Colossus could convince Cyttorak to transfer his power, or even cut off Cain Marko's connection to Cyttorak. Cain Marko would be left as a normal human. Colossus would still be a powerful mutant.
The Juggernaut, despite his incredible strength, has been defeated by surprising heroes like Professor Xavier, Cyclops, Banshee, and Lost. These heroes used their unique abilities, whether it be telepathy, strategic thinking, sonic blasts, or reality manipulation, to overcome the seemingly unstoppable villain.
Actually as said in deadpool 2, he did beat him twice. If you are talking about a fight to the death, probably juggernaut since it seems nearly impossible to kill the big guy.
Writers often take artistic licenses when dealing with Hercules' strength, as Stan Lee himself pointed out at one time. However, it is undeniable that Hercules has bested both Thor and Hulk, proving he is indeed the strongest Avenger.
Physically they're pretty evenly matched, but Thanos is just a much more skilled fighter. No stones were used in the fight. Per Joe Russo: "I would say that he's just that powerful," said Joe Russo.
This is a tricky one. If Battle Field Removal is allowed then Goku will win. But as it stands, if there is no Time Limit, no planetary destruction, and to the death. Then Juggernaut (Juggy) wins every single round 10/10.
