Other than Frodo, Sam was probably the best member of the Fellowship to bear the Ring. Yet, it was still too much to handle. Judging by the Ring's quick impact on him, it's unlikely Sam would've been able to destroy it. It really goes to show just how terrible a burden the One Ring was.
So, in the end, the Fellowship was definitely correct for believing only the fires of Mount Doom could destroy the One Ring. That's because, while there were other methods, none could be achieved by a mortal being.
Tolkien attributed Sam's resistance to the One Ring to two main factors: "In that hour of trial it was the love of his master that helped most to hold him firm, but also deep down in him lived still unconquered his plain hobbit-sense." Ultimately, Sam's greatest desire was not to defeat Sauron or transform Mordor into ...
But Frodo would not be able to do it. The answer is most assuredly yes and no. Although there was no way for Sam to force Frodo to do it, he would surely beg and plead with Frodo to throw it into the lava. But Frodo would not be able to do it.
Even if Gollum wasn't a problem, and Sam finally made it to the fiery chasm, there's the debate of whether he would throw the Ring. Seen with both Isildur and Frodo, neither of them could bring themselves to destroy it, as the Ring always corrupted them in the final moments.
He loved him and cared about him as he would for himself, or even more. So Frodo represented Sam's other self. And on the other hand, Sam functioned as Frodo's mirror, because knowing him so well, he was able to precisely guess his mind.
Though someone could start out with good intentions, the Ring would eventually corrupt them. And that is why Gandalf can't touch it. He is afraid that if he did, it would corrupt him and make him just as bad as Sauron since Sauron put so much of himself and his evil into the One Ring.
Bilbo's Compassion Protected Him From The Ring's Corruption
Luckily, Bilbo's compassion causes him to show mercy. The importance of that moment is revealed in one of Gandalf's wisest quotes when he tells Frodo that Bilbo's pity and compassion in acquiring the Ring help protect him from its corrupting power: “Pity?
If Sam had carried the Ring, then based on what happens in the books, he would have been able to resist the temptation the Ring offered and throw the Ring into the fires with little to no hesitation.
There's a big reason why this coincidence didn't clock with Gandalf, and it's because the idea of Bilbo finding the One Ring seemed out of the realm of possibility. For close to 3000 years, the One Ring was missing, with no hints as to its whereabouts.
The One Ring has the power to extend the life of any mortal indefinitely. Gollum survived after losing the Ring because its effects on him lingered as long as the Ring existed in the world.
Frodo is the person who carries the Ring because of reasons which, ultimately, make him a completely ordinary person. Frodo's Hobbit nature allows him to be more incorruptible, discreet and all but invisible to Sauron.
Morgoth also bestowed extra strength upon Sauron. Certainly the Valar could destroy the One Ring, but it was a matter for Middle-Earth and after Numenor, the Valar refrained from direct action there.
Why can the One Ring only be destroyed in Mount Doom?
The fires were the only thing hot enough to melt the Ring, but even if there was another place hot enough, it wouldn't have worked -- because Morgoth's original evils needed to be there to undo the Ring's creation. Basically, the Ring came from the powers of Mount Doom and thus had to be unmade there.
Isildur took up the hilt-shard of Narsil, Elendil's sword, and cut the One Ring from the hand of Sauron. Despite the urging of Elrond and Círdan, Gil-galad's lieutenants, Isildur did not throw the Ring into the fires of Mount Doom. He made a scroll with a description of the Ring and a copy of its fading inscription.
Therefore, especially if Galadriel had to pass Nenya to another, carrying the One Ring would have led to Galadriel's corruption. She was far too ambitious and far too powerful to continue to avoid temptation forever.
The One Ring had the power in The Lord of the Rings to corrupt the beings of Middle-earth just from being in close proximity. As a powerful wizard, Gandalf wasn't affected in quite the same way.
"Wild fantasies arose in his mind; and he saw Samwise the Strong, Hero of the Age, striding with a flaming sword across the land . . . at his command the vale of Gorgoroth became a garden of flowers and trees and brought forth fruit." What saves Sam from the temptation that overpowered Boromir is his lack of ...
The contents of Tolkiens' notes and other works weren't covered and were thus off-limits to the filmmakers. That's why Gandalf's mind coincidentally went blank — he legally couldn't name the wizards. So, the writers had Gandalf exploit a loophole by alluding to the two Istari without explicitly mentioning them.
Even if she took the One Ring and defeated Sauron, she would have eventually faded. Having seen the light of Valinor, she couldn't stay in Middle-earth indefinitely. And she needed to finally refuse power to be accepted back into Valinor. RELATED: Saruman Was Immortal in Lord of the Rings - So How Was He Killed?
The fantasy and science fiction author Marion Zimmer Bradley wrote that Frodo and Sam have the most intense love described in the book, stating that towards the end they attain "classical 'idealized friendship'" of an emotional force like that of Achilles and Patroclus in the Iliad, or David and Jonathan in the Old ...
They kiss at least four times; another time, it's specified that they don't kiss, which has interesting implications. And when they return to the Shire, Sam moves into Bag End with Frodo — no longer a servant, but an equal and a constant companion.
Frodo knows Gollum is motivated by his need for the ring, and understands this as a ring bearer himself. He sympathizes with Gollum after his conversation with Gandalf about how Bilbo spared him. He also knows he needs Gollum to find the way to Mordor, and likely wouldn't have been able to make it there without him.
