Strictly speaking, there are no real consequences for not stealing the feather either, meaning that it doesn't really matter what players decide to do. However, opting not to help Garreth Weasley by stealing the Fwooper Feather from Professor Sharp's office will lead to players missing out on a rather amusing cutscene.
With no real repercussions, players are free to pick whichever option appeals to them at that moment with little to no worry about what happens after. The only reason players might wish to steal the Feather for Garreth comes from their future interactions with the character in a quest later on.
Neither telling Natty the truth nor lying affects your relationship with Natty and the outcome of the quest The Girl from Uagadou. Both dialogue options also lead to short conversations too, since Natty doesn't have any new knowledge to offer regarding Ancient Magic.
Should I lie to Professor Sharp in Hogwarts Legacy?
You can either admit to it or lie. Own up and he'll commend you on your honesty, lie and he'll admonish you. However, this decision makes no difference to the rest of the game. You'll rarely talk to Professor Sharp after this, and the incident never comes up again.
Should You Steal The Feather For Garreth Weasley In Hogwarts Legacy
Should I steal the feather in Hogwarts Legacy?
Strictly speaking, there are no real consequences for not stealing the feather either, meaning that it doesn't really matter what players decide to do. However, opting not to help Garreth Weasley by stealing the Fwooper Feather from Professor Sharp's office will lead to players missing out on a rather amusing cutscene.
This choice doesn't affect the main story or Hogwarts Legacy's ending, so it really is just up to the player to decide which character they'd rather go with.
Is it better to be good or evil in Hogwarts Legacy?
While there is an evil outcome among the several endings in Hogwarts Legacy, for some odd reason, the dark spells themselves have no impact on the progression of the story or the world in any way (apart from the remarks from companions and NPCs).
Absolutely, you can trust Sebastian Sallow in Hogwarts Legacy. While every character in such a vast RPG comes with their own complexities and agendas, Sebastian proves himself to be a reliable ally throughout the game.
Essentially, there's no version of the story where you'll be recognised as inherently evil and rise up as a proto-Voldemort. However, this also means you won't be punished for any mischievous or immoral acts.
Following in the traditions of many story-driven, open-world titles, Hogwarts Legacy has multiple endings. There are a total of 3 possible Endings in Hogwarts Legacy that players can achieve. These have been colloquially dubbed the Good Ending, the Evil / Bad Ending, and the True Ending.
Is it better to lie or tell truth in Hogwarts Legacy?
The only difference between the two possibilities is if the player decides to be honest, then it will lead to a short discussion with Sebastian about ancient magic, where he promises to keep their secret. Other than this unique dialogue, there's no other incentives or rewards for telling Sebastian the truth.
So while there are no romance options, three of the four main houses (sorry Ravenclaw) each have an in-depth companion that you'll go on many missions with and even lead to some of the most powerful spells in the game.
Hogwarts Legacy doesn't tell us the age of our teachers, but if I had to guess, Aesop looks to be in his late 30s. Aesop has some wrinkles around his eyes, but he has yet to get any grey in his facial hair or the hair on his head.
Later, in the Undercroft, the game gives you the option to turn Sebastian in or to let him get away with the murder of his uncle. Of course, in the real world, murder is a serious crime and should always be reported.
Should You Turn Sebastian In Or Not? Players who chose not to learn the three Unforgivable Curses when they had the chance earlier but want to learn them now should choose not to turn Sebastian in; once he is gone, the only way to acquire these spells is for players to begin a new game and start over.
If you chose to 'open it', embracing the 'evil' ending, Professor Fig will be killed by the Ranrok Dragon in the cut-scene before the fight. This is a blink-and-you'll-miss-it moment, with a massive pile of debris being walloped onto your kindly mentor.
But most importantly, you can make your own quest choices that will result in different outcomes and ultimately in your own ending. However, in Hogwarts Legacy, you can't become an actual villain. The game is designed to put the player on a path to saving the world; your character is the only one who can accomplish it.
Visiting Azkaban in Hogwarts Legacy is only an option for players who chose a particular House at the start of the game, and it is only a very brief and linear visit, but it's still exciting to see and walk around such a storied locale, even briefly.
The character has an interesting story path in Hogwarts Legacy revolving around his family and past, so you would be missing out on a compelling narrative if you turn him in. If you do turn Sebastian in, it will lock out additional content that could extend your time in the Wizarding World's darker side.
