Decision Doesn't Matter Neither telling Natty the truth nor lying affects your relationship with Natty and the outcome of the quest The Girl from Uagadou. Both dialogue options also lead to short conversations too, since Natty doesn't have any new knowledge to offer regarding Ancient Magic.
Summary. The choice between Sebastian and Natty for the Hogsmeade trip in Hogwarts Legacy primarily affects the friendship and relationship with the chosen character. The choice does not have a long-term impact on the overall story or outcome of the trip, only influencing the conversations in Hogsmeade.
In the end, players should opt for whichever option they feel fits their character best, as there is no real difference between withholding or telling Sebastian the truth in Hogwarts Legacy. Editor's Note: Harry Potter creator J.K. Rowling has been accused of transphobia by those in the LGBTQ+ community.
Telling Natty the Truth - Hogwarts Legacy Cutscene
How do you choose the bad ending in Hogwarts Legacy?
If players select the first option agreeing with Professor Fig, "You're right," they'll redact their initial choice and see the good ending. Therefore, players who want to receive the bad ending should select either the second or third dialogue choices: "This power should not be kept from the world."
You shouldn't turn Sebastian in because it brings more restrictions to your experience as you approach the end of Hogwarts Legacy. However, if you need more convincing, it's important to dive into Sebastian's story and why he ends up in trouble.
The character has an interesting story path in Hogwarts Legacy revolving around his family and past, so you would be missing out on a compelling narrative if you turn him in. If you do turn Sebastian in, it will lock out additional content that could extend your time in the Wizarding World's darker side.
So according to the game, players are free to choose any option they like. But while choosing a companion for the first visit to Hogsmeade, players should go for Natsai “Natty” Onai over Sebastian Sallow.
Later, in the Undercroft, the game gives you the option to turn Sebastian in or to let him get away with the murder of his uncle. Of course, in the real world, murder is a serious crime and should always be reported.
Totally, Natty's as trustworthy as they come in Hogwarts Legacy. You won't find any sneaky business with her. She's a steadfast character that'll help you navigate through the magical world without pulling any fast ones. So, yes, put your trust in Natty, and you won't regret it.
Absolutely, you can trust Sebastian Sallow in Hogwarts Legacy. While every character in such a vast RPG comes with their own complexities and agendas, Sebastian proves himself to be a reliable ally throughout the game.
Although he supported his brother for most of his life, he became disillusioned with Ranrok's ideals for goblin supremacy when he encountered a kind witch known as Miriam Fig. He defected from Ranrok's Loyalists and started an independent life. In the end, Lodgok was killed by Ranrok for his treason.
Sebastian is very much a “the path to hell is paved with good intentions” type of character. The more people tell him that nothing good can come of this path the more he doubles down on it. No one can doubt his love for his sister or his passion but that very passion is leading him down a very dark path.
What happens if you don't turn in Sebastian in Hogwarts Legacy?
If players choose not to turn him in, the protagonist will attempt to reason with Ominis by pointing out how much Sebastian regrets what he did. Ominis will take some convincing, but he will eventually agree with the protagonist before setting off to convince Anne of the same.
By the end of the game, Sebastian and Ominis are still friends, albeit their relationship markedly changed due to in-game events. Though they are no longer as close, the door has been left ajar for the two young wizards to strengthen their bond someday, and I hope we get to see it in a future Sebinis (Ombastian?)
Of course, since Hogwarts Legacy precedes the main series by about one hundred years, Tom Riddle has yet to be born during the game's events. This same sentiment applies to most Harry Potter characters, with the single exception being Albus Dumbledore.
