Then, Dumbledore asked, "After all this time?" I think he was asking whether Snape had this Patronus for the 17 years Lily was dead, whether it changed, whether his loyalty to Lily ever wavered. "Always," Snape responded. Snape has cared for Lily since knowing her.

What does it mean when Dumbledore says after all this time and Snape says Always?

He has the same Patronus of Lily Potter's that means he always cared for Lily, despite it was one-sided love, always cared for Harry because Lily'd have wanted it. And the fact that Snape's patronus is a doe means that he still truly loves her, and that his feelings for her haven't weakened over the years.

What is the meaning of after all these years Always?

The lines "After all this time?" and "Always" reveal Snape's deep and enduring love for Lily, which he has held onto for years [1]. Snape's love for Lily is a complex mix of guilt, remorse, and genuine affection, making his character more nuanced and multi-dimensional [3].

What is the meaning of after all this time?

After all this time means after all the time that has passed. Although you are referring to the period of time from then to now, it doesn't mean up to now. It refers to a long period of time -- it is to be taken literally.

Why does Dumbledore say "Lily" when Snape casts his Patronus?

By confirming to Dumbledore that he is still in love with Lily, this shows that Snape cannot overcome the past, nor the grief of Lily's death. The fact that Snape is still in love with Lily could likely explain why his Patronus is a doe.

Why Dumbledore Said 'After All This Time?' to Snape - Harry Potter Explained

Why did Snape call Lily a Muggle?

In the book, we learn that James Potter and his friends were bullying Snape, and Lily came to his defense. Instead of accepting her act of kindness, he rejected her and called her a "mudblood" — an insult to witches and wizards with Muggle parents — despite his own impure bloodline.

Did Snape canonically call Lily a mudblood?

Snape himself called other Muggle Borns that. It took a lot of control to call Lily, well, Lily. In the heat of the moment, Snape lost control and called Lily the forbidden word. He called her a mud-blood by accident because he was frustrated that lily did not like his closest friends.

Did Severus love Harry?

In the Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows movie, Snape showed how much he loved Harry, providing him with his memories and showing that he saw Lily in him, his last words echoing this: "You have your mother's eyes."

Why is Snape's Patronus a doe?

Lily's Patronus was also a doe, which is the complimentary counterpart to her true love's stag, James. However, Snape's Patronus was less of a counterpart as it was an homage to his true love. It's revealed that his Patronus is a doe simply because he was always in love with Lily.

Why did Snape say "always"?

Snape having the same Patronus, the doe, as Lily symbolized his everlasting love and unwavering devotion towards her. He hadn't stopped loving her after their last altercation, marriage to James Potter, or death. She was his "always," his guiding light, and he protected Harry for her.

Did Dumbledore know Harry would survive?

Dumbledore knew that Harry would survive and didn't set him up for death, as earlier clues in the series hinted at his understanding of Harry's destiny. Harry's survival against Voldemort's Killing Curse revealed that Dumbledore knew all along that the Boy Who Lived was never in true danger.

How did Dumbledore get the resurrection stone?

After spending many months looking into Voldemort's past, Albus Dumbledore was able to track down the location of the ring and retrieve it. Though he had long since abandoned his personal quest to find the Deathly Hallows, he immediately realised that this ring contained the Resurrection Stone.

How did Harry survive Avada Kedavra in the forest?

The Elder Wand, which Harry mastered, protected him during the Battle of Hogwarts and prevented Avada Kedavra from killing him. Voldemort's use of Harry's blood inadvertently kept Lily's protective charm alive and allowed Harry to survive the Killing Curse in the forest.

Did Voldemort know Harry was a Horcrux?

Notably, Voldemort appeared to be entirely unaware of this split, as he later created a seventh Horcrux in his quest to have six, and continued to target Harry Potter despite him now holding part of Voldemort's own soul.

Is Neville the chosen one?

While most fans agree that Harry is the unrefuted Chosen One, the final Deathly Hallows film (in particular) sways heavily toward highlighting a heroic Neville, revitalizing the debate regarding which boy is better suited for the iconic title. "The one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord approaches ...

Is Harry Snape's son?

The movies follow the books closely enough that they aren't really separate universes, except for the fourth movie. There isn't any truly compelling evidence that Snape is Harry's father, because all the points you raise are explained. Snape hated Harry because Harry reminded him of the man who "stole" Lily.

What is Voldemort's Patronus?

No, Voldemort cannot produce patronus because he can't love which is because he was concieved under the effects of a love potion.

Did Lily ever love Snape?

Lily Only Ever Saw Snape As A Friend

As much as people romanticize Snape's infatuation with Lily, the fact she did not love him back romantically is ignored. The fact Snape and Lily were only friends, and she only saw it as such, reveals a lot about his refusal to respect her boundaries.

Why is Snape the half-blood prince?

Family. Snape's family background is mostly shown in flashbacks during the course of the last three novels. Snape was born to Eileen Prince, a witch, and Tobias Snape, a Muggle, making him a half-blood (hence the name, "Half-Blood Prince").

Did Lily ever forgive Snape?

She missed Snape, but she knew she could never forgive him. Snape never stopped trying to make amends. But Lily remained steadfast. She could not, would not, forgive him.

Why did Snape hate Hermione?

Why did Snape hate Hermione? I think Snape was probably initially impressed with Hermione, but later frustrated with her, for a few reasons. Hermione was very book-smart and could come up with answers quickly, but didn't seem to be very good at improvising or trying to improve on existing Magic.

What did Lily call Snape?

Lily called Severus “Snivellus “ because only a Snivellus would call his best friend a filthy little mudblood. Severus became Snivellus when he was a bigoted bully, attacking a friend whom actually stopped his enemies from bullying him.

Did Snape make the branch fall on Petunia?

During one such interaction between Lily and Snape, he notices Petunia spying on them, and in response to her typically catty remarks upon being called out, Snape causes a branch to fall and hit Petunia on her head.

What is Snape's bloodline?

The Snapes were related to the pure-blood Prince family. Sometime before 1960, pure-blood witch Eileen Prince married Muggle Tobias Snape. They had one child, half-blood wizard Severus Snape. The marriage seemed to be unhappy, as they lived in near-destitution, frequently argued, and were neglectful of their son.