You receive 11 Galleons in addition to 180XP and the Mermaid Mask. "I did. And I'm keeping it". Grace is annoyed but you still receive 180XP and the Mermaid Mask.
What happens if you keep the astrolabe in Hogwarts Legacy?
Choosing to keep the Astrolabe or demanding a reward will certainly annoy Grace, but players will ultimately end up with exactly the same rewards regardless of what they choose. They'll get 180 XP and the Mermaid Mask: a cosmetic item that can be used to customize the appearance of a piece of Gear.
What happens if you keep the repository a secret Hogwarts Legacy?
If you decide not to open the repository, Professor Fig will still get crushed by a rockslide – but he'll survive the incident. Following the battle against Ranrok, the two of you will then contain the ancient magic inside the repository and seal the Keeper's oath.
What happens if you keep the power Hogwarts Legacy?
If you chose to 'keep it contained', opting for the 'good' ending, Professor Fig will still die. Although he survives the fight in this case, he will over-exert himself and pass away as you try to put the ancient power back in the Repository. The Hogwarts Legacy ending is something of a no-win scenario, then.
To get the good ending in Hogwarts Legacy, players will need to respond with "I intend to keep it contained here," to which Fig will react positively. He'll follow this up by asking them how long they intend to keep ancient magic a secret, to which they'll need to reply with "I shall keep it secret forever."
Hogwarts Legacy Keeping The Astrolabe And Giving It Back Outcomes
Should I give back the astrolabe Hogwarts?
Once you've acquired the astrolabe, make your way back to Grace to return her family heirloom and complete this Side Quest! Upon speaking to Grace, you'll be given three different dialogue options but regardless of your selection, you'll always be rewarded with 180XP and the Mermaid Mask.
Later, in the Undercroft, the game gives you the option to turn Sebastian in or to let him get away with the murder of his uncle. Of course, in the real world, murder is a serious crime and should always be reported.
In the Bad Ending, your character again struggles to handle the Ancient Magic unleashed by Ranrok's defeat, but instead of getting help from Professor Fig, you absorb some of that magic into yourself. Gaining an extra burst of strength, your character is then able to seal away the remainder of the magic on their own.
Following in the traditions of many story-driven, open-world titles, Hogwarts Legacy has multiple endings. There are a total of 3 possible Endings in Hogwarts Legacy that players can achieve. These have been colloquially dubbed the Good Ending, the Evil / Bad Ending, and the True Ending.
You can chose to contain or control the reserves of dark magic the Keepers are sworn to protect. Any option you chose results in the same boss fight against Ranrok, and Professor Fig dying. There's no way to save him even if you made the “good” decisions.
Once you've knocked Ranrok's health down all the way, you'll be treated to a well-earned cutscene. This also wraps up The Final Repository quest. But while the big boss has been defeated, the game isn't over yet.
Should I keep the secret for now or forever in Hogwarts?
Choosing "I intend to keep it contained here" causes Fig to breathe a sigh of relief, knowing your plan is to keep it contained and not repeat the mistakes of Isidora, and you can then choose whether to keep it a secret "for now" or "forever". Regardless of your choice here, Fig agrees this is the right path.
Best answer. Totally keep the astrolabe! It's not just a fancy wizarding knick-knack; it's super useful in the game for certain quests and exploring around those magical locations.
Once you find the Pinch-Smedley family's lost astrolabe, you must return to Grace on the docks. You can then choose to return her family's heirloom, request higher pay for retrieving the item, or keep it for yourself. In any case, the base rewards for completing the quest remain the same: 180 Exp.
To unlock the good ending in Hogwarts Legacy, you must choose to contain the Ancient Magic in the Repository and carry the secret forever. The professor will admire you for this decision and stay by your side. You will seal the Magic as the keeper.
Morality explained. While you can make certain choices and use spells that may be considered morally questionable, you cannot canonically be evil in Hogwarts Legacy. Essentially, there's no version of the story where you'll be recognised as inherently evil and rise up as a proto-Voldemort.
Should you turn Sebastian in or not Hogwarts Legacy?
Should You Turn Sebastian In Or Not? Players who chose not to learn the three Unforgivable Curses when they had the chance earlier but want to learn them now should choose not to turn Sebastian in; once he is gone, the only way to acquire these spells is for players to begin a new game and start over.
The “good” ending in Hogwarts Legacy is the result of a principled stance against the temptation to wield unbridled power. When faced with the decision to either open or contain the Final Repository of Ancient Magic, players who choose to protect its secrets opt for a path of selflessness and integrity.
After completing Hogwarts Legacy's story, players will gain access to two main story new quests; these being Weasley's Watchful Eye and The House Cup. The former requires players to complete the Field Guide, which means finding every single missing page.
Can I get the good ending if I learn the unforgivable curses?
Can you get a bad ending if you use Unforgivable Curses? No, using Unforgivable Curses in the game will not result in a bad ending. The overall narrative remains unchanged, and there are no significant long-term consequences or repercussions for the player.
You shouldn't turn Sebastian in because it brings more restrictions to your experience as you approach the end of Hogwarts Legacy. However, if you need more convincing, it's important to dive into Sebastian's story and why he ends up in trouble.
