While Harris might have been the most faithful Dumbledore, Gambon's is certainly the best. Most of the character inconsistencies aren't the actor's fault, and Gambon had enough time to perfect Dumbledore until the character's emotional peak in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince.

Who is the better Dumbledore on Reddit?

A bit of both. Richard Harris is definitely the kind & understanding Dumbledore from the books but Michael Gambon is definitely the “powerful wizard who Voldemort fears” Dumbledore also from the books. I think Harris could absolutely have pulled off Dumbledore in the later books.

Why did they replace Dumbledore?

Richard Harris initially portrayed Albus Dumbledore in the first two Harry Potter movies but was replaced due to his declining health. He tragically passed away from Hodgkin's lymphoma at the age of 72. Michael Gambon took over the role of Dumbledore and played him throughout the rest of the Harry Potter film series.

Who's stronger, Dumbledore or Gandalf?

Dumbledore kicks some serious ass, especially when it comes to wizarding duels, but in a contest of all-out brawls, the points have to go to Gandalf. Gandalf will frequently throw himself into the heat of battle, dispatching orc after orc with his sword and staff combo.

Which Dumbledore is more book accurate?

Richard Harris

Although he did not get enough screen time in the movies, making him more of a bystander than a pivotal character, his portrayal of Dumbledore was more faithful to the book version than any other actor's.

Why I Preferred Richard Harris over Michael Gambon as Dumbledore in Harry Potter

Was Grindelwald better than Voldemort?

So transitive law, Voldemort is far more powerful than Grindelwald. Grindelwald is nowhere near the power level of Voldemort. You have to actually interpret the story, you can't use CGI effects to determine power level.

Could any wizard beat Dumbledore?

With or without the Elder Wand, Dumbledore is invincible in traditional wizard duels. Dumbledore has studied nearly every branch of magic in intimate detail, including obscure and unusual spells, and he could beat Harry with just one or two spells if they fought.

Is Dumbledore more powerful than Snape?

Snape is an objectively powerful wizard, though perhaps not as powerful as some other people have suggested. He is nowhere near Dumbledore, though I give him a very slight edge over McGonagall (a powerful and skilled witch in her own right).

Could Dumbledore easily beat Voldemort?

Albus Dumbledore is the most obvious person who can defeat Voldemort, outside of the Salazar Slytherin vs Voldemort debate, and the Dark Lord seemed to realize it. Rowling herself has explicitly stated in the books that Dumbledore is the only person Voldemort fears and recognizes as a genuine threat to his own power.

Can Voldemort beat Dumbledore?

This is one of the few wizards that readers actually see face Voldemort in duel. Albus Dumbledore essentially defeats the Dark Lord in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix.

How did Dumbledore age so much?

They continued: "I speculate the reason for the difference in age is perspective. In the films themselves we see Dumbledore as he actually is in those years, but in the two flashbacks we get during the main series one of them is from Tom Riddle's perspective and one is from Dumbledore's perspective himself.

How old was Dumbledore when he died?

Albus Dumbledore, for example, died when he was 115 years old, which was relatively young for a wizard. Nicholas Flamel and his wife lived more than 600 years thanks to the Philosopher's Stone, but regular wizards can live between 150 and 200 years. The Trolley Lady, for example, is around 190 years old.

Why is Dumbledore so different in the third movie?

A couple of things happened. One, the Dumbledore of the first two movies was played by Richard Harris, who came across as professional and kind. Two, he was replaced by Michael Gambon who famously Does Not Read The Books and only reads scripts. Basically, Michael Gambon only plays himself.

Why is Richard Harris a better Dumbledore?

He Had Childlike Wonder

Richard Harris makes a perfect Dumbledore in the early years of Harry Potter because, despite the fact that he is presented to appear ancient, he still seems like someone who looks at the world with a sense of childlike wonder and excitement. This is ideal for relating to young Harry.

Who is most loyal to Dumbledore?

10 Severus Snape

Despite her rejection of him when they were kids, Snape remained loyal to Lily and out of his undying love for her and became the most essential player in the game to take down the Dark Lord. Risking his life countless times, his loyalty to Dumbledore never wavered.

Could Dumbledore speak Parseltongue?

Albus Dumbledore recognised, but did not speak, Parseltongue.

Could Snape beat McGonagall?

When it comes to the area of Transfiguration, McGonagall definitely has the upper hand. But when it comes to inventing spells, the Dark Arts, Legilimency and Occlumency, Snape has the edge. McGonagall is surprisingly skilled in the Dark Arts but not on the same level as Snape.

Could Dumbledore have defeated Draco?

Could Dumbledore have beat Draco and the Death Eaters if he tried to? Yes, though overall it would be pointless, and Dumbledore knew that. Dumbledore knew his days were numbered, even if he beat Draco and the intruders, he wouldn't be long for the world.

Who is the strongest wizard of all time?

Was Snape smarter than Dumbledore?

Snape is brilliant, probably the smartest in his class. Very knowledgable with potions and Dark Arts (and Defense against the dark arts). However, he isn't close to Voldemort or Dumbledore because none of his accomplishments really show that he was on the same level as Voldemort or Dumbledore.

Who is the most powerful wizard before Dumbledore?

Formerly known as Tom Marvolo Riddle, Lord Voldemort was the most formidable evil wizard in the entire universe. Until Harry Potter, Voldemort's magical prowess was practically unmatched, and no one could stand a chance against him. His fascination with the Dark Arts is very famous.

Was Harry or Hermione more powerful?

Harry has his superior defensive magical at his disposal, but Hermione is more skilled in protective charms and enchantments. Either skillset could earn them a victory in a duel.

Can Hermione defeat Voldemort?

She was famously intelligent, having solved most of Harry Potter's mysteries with her quick wit and resourcefulness. Therefore, it is not unimaginable that Hermione could have defeated Lord Voldemort had she had a chance.

Is Salazar Slytherin more powerful than Voldemort?

Just exactly how powerful were Godric Gryffindor, Salazar Slytherin, Helga Hufflepuff and Rowena Ravenclaw? Oh, using pure speculation, I would say the greatness of the Hogwart's Founders lay somewhere between not quite as powerful as Merlin, but more powerful than Dumbledore, Voldemort or Grindelwal…