The Doom of Mandos said that the Elves who left to fight Morgoth were exiled because they killed their own kin. The doors of Valinor would be shut to them by the Valar. This included all the Elves that left Valinor to fight Morgoth, even if they didn't kill their own kind, such as Galadriel and her brothers.

Why can't the Elves just go back to Valinor?

Put simply, the Elves can't return to Valinor in The Rings of Power because their work in Middle-earth is unfinished.

Why were the Elves banned from Valinor?

The purpose of this ban was to prevent a longing for the immortality of those in the Undying Lands. So, though the easternmost part of Tol Eressëa was at times visible to those in Númenor, they were banned from visiting there, or any other part of Aman.

Why can't you come back from the Undying Lands?

Beings In LOTR's Undying Lands Will Still Eventually Die

There, the Elf can rest and contemplate their life. Then, they are eventually granted a body by Mandos and returned to Valinor. When a mortal being dies, whether in Middle-earth or Aman, their soul also wanders the Halls of Mandos.

Why did Galadriel refuse to return to Valinor?

Although in the latest version of the story, Galadriel's story changed significantly, far from joining Fëanor's rebellion, she opposed him in nearly everything. And that she wished to leave Valinor and go to the vast world of Middle-earth, to give free rein there to her talents.

Aragorn vs Sauron unreleased scene (better quality) - edited

Why can't Sauron go to Valinor?

Because it would have been a massive plot hole that breaks the logic of the story. The Valar are orders of magnitude more powerful than Sauron, even at full potential just after his fall into the influence of Melkor, or any force Sauron could control.

What Elves never went to Valinor?

All those Elves who never reached Valinor are "Dark Elves." In the First Age, the Sindar viewed the term "Moriquendi" as offensive, so the Noldorin Exiles gave the name Úmanyar ("Those not of Aman") to those who started the journey but did not finish it.

Why was Aragorn not allowed in the Undying Lands?

Men were never allowed to enter the Undying Lands after the fall of Numenor and any attempts to reach the lands would result in failure or disaster. Aragorn, despite his heroic deeds, likely wouldn't have accepted an invitation to ensure his duties as king.

Is Frodo immortal in the Undying Lands?

It has come to my attention that many people who read the books or watch The Lord of the Rings films assume that Frodo, once arrived in the Undying Lands, is granted immortality. I mean, it does say “undying”. Unfortunately, as you've probably guessed, that's not the case.

What happens to Elves when they go to Valinor?

And within Valinor is the domain of Mandos, Middle-earth's god of the afterlife. The Halls of Mandos are a system of great caverns and underground halls lined with god-woven tapestries depicting all of history. When elves die, their spirits travel to the Halls, where they rest for a time as disembodied shades.

Why can't Arwen go to Valinor later?

Yet no mortal can survive forever. And after their marriage, both Aragorn and Arwen are mortal. Arwen, therefore, could not set foot in the Undying Lands without special permission. And she wouldn't be likely to go after it in the end.

Why can't humans go to Valinor?

Firstly, being there does not confer immortality, contrary to what the Númenóreans supposed. Secondly, those mortals like Frodo who are allowed to go there will eventually choose to die.

Why weren t Men allowed in Valinor?

This is implied in the Akallabeth, where men might be 'burnt out' by too much proximity to the Ainur. However, the refusal of the Valar to admit men may also be a consequence of men being corrupted early after awakening by Melkor, or his agents.

Why didn't Gandalf take ring to Valinor?

In the Fellowship of the Ring Book 2 Chapter 2 "The Council of Elrond", the potential for sending the ring over the Sea to Valinor is discussed. In it, Elrond notes: 'And they who dwell beyond the Sea would not receive it: for good or ill it belongs to Middle-earth; it is for us who still dwell here to deal with it.

Has anyone ever returned from Valinor?

No. They can not. Even if they desired it. Once in Aman beyond the Circles of the World there was no return.

Who was the last elf to leave Middle-earth?

At that time, Círdan would abandon the Grey Havens and finally travel the Straight Road himself. On some unknown date, he sailed west aboard the Last Ship with his kinsman Celeborn, but when he did so, he took with him the last living memory of the Elder Days in Middle-earth.

Is Gimli the last Dwarf?

Though Gimli has no children, he is not the last Dwarf of Middle-earth. After the fall of Sauron, his people continued to thrive in the Lonely Mountain. Gimli made his home in Rohan, in the Glittering Caves of Aglarond, and many of his kinsfolk came with him.

What happened to Legolas after LOTR?

After the War

After the death of King Elessar, Legolas made a ship in Ithilien, and through Anduin, he left Middle-earth to go over the sea. His strong friendship with Gimli prompted him to invite Gimli to go to the Undying Lands; making him the first and only Dwarf to do so.

Does Eowyn give up her immortality?

Arwen reciprocated Aragorn's love, and on the mound of Cerin Amroth they committed themselves to marrying each other. In making that choice, Arwen gave up the Elvish immortality available to her as a daughter of Elrond, and agreed to remain in Middle-earth instead of travelling to the Undying Lands.

Did Galadriel refuse the Undying Lands in the books?

After Morgoth's defeat at the end of the First Age, elves like Galadriel were pardoned and offered a return to the land they abandoned. Galadriel refused, partly because she believed her people had no reason to need pardoning, but more because she always wanted to witness Middle-earth and rule a kingdom there.

Did Merry and Pippin go to Undying Lands?

Then, of course, when Frodo chose to go to the Undying Lands with the Elves, Merry, Pippin, and Sam accompanied him to the Grey Havens to say their goodbyes to him and Bilbo.

Is Galadriel the last elf from Valinor?

No, Galadriel / Artanis was not the last surviving elf born in Aman. Her cousin and kinslayer, prince Maglor(1), was born in Valinor too, if you go strictly by the people who survived all ages of Middle-earth and did not die and subsequently go to Halls of Mandos.

Did Legolas ever go to Valinor?

By special permission of the Valar, the Hobbits Frodo Baggins, Bilbo Baggins, and Samwise Gamgee were also permitted to go to Valinor, as they had once borne the One Ring of Sauron. Later, after the death of Aragorn, Legolas the Elf would sail to Valinor and bring with him Gimli the Dwarf.

Do Elves get reborn in Valinor?

Spirits of dead Elves go to the Halls of Mandos in Valinor, a sort of Earthly Paradise, for an afterlife. After a period of rest that serves as "cleansing", their spirits are clothed in bodies identical to their old ones.