Why the Time Turner Couldn't Have Saved Harry's Parents | Fandom. The time turner couldn't have been used to save Harry's parents because it was too far back in time; you cannot go back more than five hits without there being very bad consequences. They saved Buckbeak because he was about to die three hours before.

Why not use Time-Turner to save Sirius?

In OotP, saving Sirius would have caused a time paradox.

Harry would have had to jump out of somewhere to change what he already knew had happened, right under his slightly younger self's nose. There would have been no way of doing it without causing a time paradox.

Why wasn't the Time-Turner used?

The Time-Turner is only used in one book and raises questions about why it isn't used to prevent other tragedies in the series. J.K. Rowling admitted that using time travel in the series caused problems and retroactively implemented strict rules to avoid plot holes, ultimately destroying all Time-Turners.

Why didn't Harry use the Time-Turner to save Dumbledore?

IIRC, you can only use the time-turner to go back 5 hours or thereabouts. Any more than that could seriously harm whoever is using the time turner.

Why couldn t they use the Time-Turner to stop Voldemort?

These instances followed Rowling's stance on self-fulfilling prophecies. With the established Harry Potter time travel rules, Harry and his friends never had the option of traveling back in the past to kill Voldemort. If they were to do so, Voldemort would already be dead in the present timeline.

Major Issues with the Time Turner in Harry Potter

Why would McGonagall give Hermione a Time-Turner?

Hermione Granger received one from Professor McGonagall in 1993, so that she could attend more classes in her third year than time would allow.

Why did McGonagall trust Hermione with the Time-Turner?

Perhaps McGonagall saw Hermione's potential and knew that someone like her could show that the Time-Turner had applications for students looking to take on extra credit at school or, in the case of Prisoner of Azkaban's finale, save innocent people from evil.

Why didn't Fawkes save Dumbledore?

The fact that Fawkes, who sacrificed to save Dumbledore's life at the Battle of the Department of Mysteries, didn't come to his aid at the Battle of the Astronomy Tower hints to the true nature of the headmaster's death, meaning Fawkes may understand he was killed by his own orders.

Did Dumbledore plan to sacrifice Harry?

Albus Dumbledore seemed to set Harry up for death in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, but clues from earlier in the series show he always knew the boy would survive. The headmaster was always something of a question mark in the Harry Potter series since it was never quite clear what he did or didn't know.

How many turns did Hermione and Harry turn the Time-Turner to go back in time in order to save Sirius?

She turned the small hourglass on the end of the chain three times. Ending up in a broom closet off the Entrance Hall, Hermione revealed to Harry that they had just gone back in time three hours.

Why didn't Hermione save Dobby?

Honestly, Hermione knew Dobby was a lost case... nothing could have revived Dobby after the attack or she would have definitely helped Harry with Dobby considering she was the girl who started S.P.E.W(Society for the Elfish welfare) and fought for elf rights. There was nothing to be done at that point.

What happened to Hermione's Time-Turner?

Hermione found her third year stressful with the extra class load, and therefore decided to drop Divination, which she despised, and Muggle Studies, which she did not find very useful, given that she was a Muggle-born. This allowed her to have a normal schedule once again, and she returned her Time-Turner.

What happens to wizards who meddle with time?

Dumbledore first stresses the importance of Hermione and Harry being unseen, and then later Hermione tells us that witches and wizards who have meddled with time carelessly have caused terrible damage, sometimes even killing their past or future selves and thereby completely destroying the semblance of logic within ...

Where did Sirius Black go with Buckbeak?

Sirius kept Buckbeak with him while on the run during the 1994–1995 school year, and later kept him in his mother's bedroom while in hiding at 12 Grimmauld Place.

Does Hermione howl at Lupin in the book?

Howling Like A Werewolf

After Lupin is turned, he is about to come after Harry and his friends when he hears another howl from deep in the forest, and rushes off in search of the creature who made it... which turns out to be future-Hermione, howling to lead Lupin away from her friends.

Who threw the stones in Prisoner of Azkaban?

Hermione were fated to throw the stones. Hermione did not think that she had to throw the stones in order to maintain a consistent timeline. She just did throw the stones, she chose to throw the stones.

Did Snape sacrifice his life for Harry?

Having loved Lily all his life, Snape agreed to make amends for her death by acting as a double agent to keep Harry safe. He risked his life every day, as the slightest notion that he was betraying Voldemort would have had horrific consequences.

Why did Dumbledore let Draco disarm him?

Ultimately, it's a good thing that Dumbledore's plans didn't work out because if Draco hadn't disarmed the headmaster, Harry wouldn't have gained the Elder Wand's power when he later disarmed Draco. This was proof that, unlike Dumbledore, Harry was destined to reunite the Hallows and become Master of Death all along.

Why did Dumbledore want Snape to have the wand?

Therefore, I think Dumbledore did actually want Snape to have the Wand if only to protect himself. He did not morally feel like he could leave Snape to face Voldemort without any way of saving his own life. That did not, however, work out as planned, so as Dumbledore says, “Poor Severus” (DH 721).

Why didn't Fawkes save Snape?

Because once Dumbledore died, Fawkes left the castle. Dumbledore was the only thing tying him there essentially, so without him he was free to go. That's why he didn't come back to save Snape.

Is Bill Weasley a werewolf?

Although he wasn't turned into a werewolf, he did develop some wolfish tendencies such as a liking for very rare steaks. He married Fleur on 1 August 1997, although their wedding was disrupted by the arrival of Death Eaters following the fall of the Ministry of Magic.

What was Dumbledore's biggest mistake?

Albus Dumbledore was the most powerful and intelligent wizard in the Harry Potter series, but he made a huge mistake. In Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Dumbledore doesn't communicate properly with Harry, leaving him vulnerable to Voldemort's plans.

Why didn t McGonagall marry?

Thinking about her future, she realised that wedding a Muggle who didn't know that she was a witch would mean Minerva would follow her mother's footsteps and live unhappily with her wand locked away, shredding all of her ambitions.

Who knew Hermione had a time turner?

Therefore, Snape could have accused Harry and Hermione that they used it to go back in time to free Sirius if he'd known about the time-turner. So the only teachers who knew about it would be Dumbledore and McGonagall.