Yes, if they were reincarnated there, although they can sail back to Middle Earth if they wish or are sent. Glorfindel spent about a thousand years in Valinor before being sent back to Middle Earth. Dead elves can either be resurrected, re-embodied or reincarnated.

Has anyone ever returned from Valinor?

No. They can not. Even if they desired it. Once in Aman beyond the Circles of the World there was no return.

Can you come and go from Valinor?

Once an Elf is granted passage from the Grey Havens to Valinor, they sail across the Sundering Seas and enter the Undying Lands, never to return to Middle-earth. Valinor is its own sort of heaven, an eternal land of paradise for Elves to live among the gods.

Can someone come back from the Undying Lands?

Beings In LOTR's Undying Lands Will Still Eventually Die

There, the Elf can rest and contemplate their life. Then, they are eventually granted a body by Mandos and returned to Valinor.

What happens if a human goes to Valinor?

However, if a mortal were somehow to slip past Manwe, hidden among elves and masked in the glow of their immortality, most believe it to be unlikely that they would survive long in Valinor. This is because their body and soul would not be able to find harmony within the land without the gift of the Valar.

Why Couldn't Men go to Valinor? Middle-earth Explained

Do mortals become immortal in Valinor?

They note, too, that a mortal's stay in Valinor is only temporary, not conferring immortality, just as, in medieval Christian theology, the Earthly Paradise is only a preparation for the Celestial Paradise that is above.

Why Men can't go to Valinor?

This is implied in the Akallabeth, where men might be 'burnt out' by too much proximity to the Ainur. However, the refusal of the Valar to admit men may also be a consequence of men being corrupted early after awakening by Melkor, or his agents.

Does Aragorn ever go to the Undying Lands?

Men were never allowed to enter the Undying Lands after the fall of Numenor and any attempts to reach the lands would result in failure or disaster. Aragorn, despite his heroic deeds, likely wouldn't have accepted an invitation to ensure his duties as king.

Is Frodo immortal in the Undying Lands?

It has come to my attention that many people who read the books or watch The Lord of the Rings films assume that Frodo, once arrived in the Undying Lands, is granted immortality. I mean, it does say “undying”. Unfortunately, as you've probably guessed, that's not the case.

Why can't Galadriel return to Valinor?

The Silmarillion or Unfinished Tales revealed details about Elves and the War of Wrath. Certain Elves were once cursed by Doom of Mandos preventing them from returning to Valinor, including Galadriel.

Can Elves come back from Valinor?

Yes, if they were reincarnated there, although they can sail back to Middle Earth if they wish or are sent. Glorfindel spent about a thousand years in Valinor before being sent back to Middle Earth. Dead elves can either be resurrected, re-embodied or reincarnated.

What Elves never went to Valinor?

All those Elves who never reached Valinor are "Dark Elves." In the First Age, the Sindar viewed the term "Moriquendi" as offensive, so the Noldorin Exiles gave the name Úmanyar ("Those not of Aman") to those who started the journey but did not finish it.

Is Gimli the only dwarf to go to Valinor?

Legolas and Gimli arrive in Valinor; Gimli being the first and only Dwarve to enter Valinor.

Was Galadriel banned from returning to Valinor?

Being one of the chief leaders of the Noldorin rebellion, Galadriel was not allowed to return and a ban was set upon her, to which she replied that she had no wish to do so.

Did Galadriel refuse to go to Valinor?

She wasn't forbidden to return. After the War of Wrath, the Valar invited the Eldar in Middle-earth (including the Noldor) once more to come to Valinor (Tol Eressëa more specifically). She remained in Middle-earth out of pride and misbelief [and a personal ban against the Noldorin leaders of the rebellion].

Who destroyed Valinor?

Darkening of Valinor was the destruction of the Two Trees of Valinor, by Morgoth and Ungoliant in Y.T. 1495. The five Valian Years between the Darkening and the rising of the Sun was known as the Long Night.

Is Gimli the last Dwarf?

Though Gimli has no children, he is not the last Dwarf of Middle-earth. After the fall of Sauron, his people continued to thrive in the Lonely Mountain. Gimli made his home in Rohan, in the Glittering Caves of Aglarond, and many of his kinsfolk came with him.

What happened to Legolas after LOTR?

After the War

After the death of King Elessar, Legolas made a ship in Ithilien, and through Anduin, he left Middle-earth to go over the sea. His strong friendship with Gimli prompted him to invite Gimli to go to the Undying Lands; making him the first and only Dwarf to do so.

Did Merry and Pippin go to Undying Lands?

Then, of course, when Frodo chose to go to the Undying Lands with the Elves, Merry, Pippin, and Sam accompanied him to the Grey Havens to say their goodbyes to him and Bilbo.

Why can't Arwen go to Valinor after Aragorn dies?

And after their marriage, both Aragorn and Arwen are mortal. Arwen, therefore, could not set foot in the Undying Lands without special permission.

Does Aragorn outlive Arwen?

In the year 121 of the Fourth Age, after Aragorn's death, Arwen died of a broken heart at Cerin Amroth in Lórien, and was buried there one year after the death of Aragorn, to whom she had been wedded for 122 years. She was 2901 years old.

Why didn't Gandalf take ring to Valinor?

In the Fellowship of the Ring Book 2 Chapter 2 "The Council of Elrond", the potential for sending the ring over the Sea to Valinor is discussed. In it, Elrond notes: 'And they who dwell beyond the Sea would not receive it: for good or ill it belongs to Middle-earth; it is for us who still dwell here to deal with it.

Can anyone just sail to Valinor?

Only the Elves could sail there by the Straight Road, if in ships capable of passing out of the Spheres of the Earth.

Who decides who goes to Valinor?

How could Frodo and Bilbo accompany Gandalf to Valinor if no mortals could ever set foot on the shore? The Valar made the rules, and the Valar could grant exceptions. It wasn't physically impossible for mortals to go there, because Ar-Pharazôn the Golden and his gigantic army all landed there.