Society of the Snow essentially tells the same story of the Andes survivors, but its approach is more serious and dignified. As opposed to the earlier movie, Society of the Snow never attempts any unreal exuberance, and the portrayal always remains respectful.
In the end, the story Alive and Society of the Snow are telling might be the exact same one. The details of the Uruguayan Air Force Flight 571 crash haven't changed. But the way the two movies approach the story – and the care that is taken with the story itself, is very, very different.
Are the survivors of Society of the Snow still Alive?
Since they were very young when the accident happened, almost all sixteen of them are still alive — Javier Methol and José Luis "Coche" Inciarte died in 2015 and 2023, respectively. The survivors met on October 13, 2022, to pay tribute to the victims 50 years after the crash.
Alive was very good for it's time. However, Society of the Snow is far more accurate to the actual events, and it isn't white washed. I think there is far more tension in Society of the Snow as well. It's English dubbed, so you don't need subtitles.
Based on the 1974 nonfiction book by Piers Paul Read, the film starred Ethan Hawke as Nando Parrado, one of 16 survivors (out of 45 on board) rescued two months after the accident.
Society Of The Snow VS Alive - Which Movie Is Better & The True Story?
Which movie is better, Alive or Society of the Snow?
Society of the Snow tells a more authentic and dignified story of the Andes plane crash survivors compared to the Hollywoodized version in Alive. The movie portrays the trauma and suffering of the survivors in a tangible way, making their experiences feel more genuine and relatable.
Society of the Snow (Spanish: La sociedad de la nieve) is a 2023 survival drama film directed by J. A. Bayona and based on Pablo Vierci's 2009 book of the same name, which details the true story of a Uruguayan rugby team's experience in 1972 after Uruguayan Air Force Flight 571 crashed in the Andes mountains.
Netflix's Society of the Snow might just be the most accurate retelling yet of the Andes disaster – with director JA Bayona explaining that he prepared for the film "like a documentary" and interviewing survivors "for hours". "We did extensive research," he explained during an exclusive interview with RadioTimes.com.
How many of the Andes survivors are still Alive today?
Of the 16 survivors, 14 are still alive. José Luis “Coche” Inciarte died in 2023 of cancer, per the AFP, as did Javier Methol in 2015. Sergio Catalan, the herdsman who encountered Fernando Parrado and Roberto Canessa after their 10-day trek through the Andes from the crash site, died in 2020 at the age of 91.
JA Bayona, famous for directing his fair share of hit films, decided to remake this film thirty years later. It's called Society of the Snow and it's on Netflix later this month. In 1972 a plane crashed in the Andes Mountains due to inclement weather. It had a Uruguayan rugby team aboard.
Why didn't they make a fire in Society of the Snow?
The place where the plane crashed was not strategically visible, so it would have been pointless to try to make a fire. Furthermore, they didn't have enough flammable objects to cause such a big fire, which is why the lighter was used for cigarettes but never a signal fire.
The next day, Oct. 13, 1972, the plane took off again and was flying through the Andes when the co-pilot at the controls started to descend, mistakenly thinking he'd cleared the mountain range. The aircraft hit a mountain, breaking both wings off and causing the fuselage to slide down a mountain.
How many days did the people from Society of the Snow survive?
"Society of the Snow" is based on the remarkable true story of a 1972 plane crash in the Andes. For 72 days, 16 people managed to survive, dealing with extreme cold, starvation, and dehydration.
What happened to the rugby team that crashed in the Andes?
Uruguayan Air Force flight 571, flight of an airplane charted by a Uruguayan amateur rugby team that crashed in the Andes Mountains in Argentina on October 13, 1972, the wreckage of which was not located for more than two months. Of the 45 people aboard the plane, only 16 survived the ordeal.
Fernando "Nando" Seler Parrado Dolgay (born 9 December 1949) is a Uruguayan businessman, producer, motivational speaker and television presenter, and former rugby player and racing driver. He is one of the sixteen survivors of the Uruguayan Air Force Flight 571 which crashed in the Andes on 13 October 1972.
Sadly, Methol was the first of the plane crash survivors to pass away as he died of cancer in 2015. After losing his wife Liliana during the events following the plane crash, he remarried Ana María with whom he had four more children. He worked in the tobacco industry until his death at the age of 79.
“What remains of the plane is still in a place where, in general, there is snow. It is at least 10 metres below where it was during the 72 days that the survivors were sheltered,” says Moraga.
Which is more accurate, Alive or Society of the Snow?
Summary. Society of the Snow offers a fresh perspective on the Andes plane crash with added layers of realism, making it a more accurate depiction than Alive. Society of the Snow has an entirely South American cast, speaking mainly in Spanish, which adds an authentic touch to the story.
Did the actors in Society of the Snow have to lose weight?
- Juan Antonio Bayona wanted 'Society of the Snow' to exude realism, so he sought scientific advice to ensure that 30 actors lost 30 kilos within a few months, mirroring the victims of the Uruguayan Air Force Flight 571 crash in the Andes in 1972.
All the sources claim they hiked 60 km in ten days until they encountered Sergio Catalan at the confluence of Rio del Azufre and Rio del Portillo rivers.
Believing he'd overflown Curicó (a geographical marker), the co-pilot misread the plane's instruments and, after beginning the descent, struck a mountain ridge. Some Society of the Snow filming took place at the actual crash site in the Andes.
