Because Jack didn't actually want to become Captain of the Flying Dutchman. He just wanted to not be dead,and controlling the heart meant Davy Jones (or the Kraken) wouldn't kill him. Stabbing the heart was mostly a backup plan. Because being immortal and living forever isn't the same thing as living forever.

Why did Will Turner have to cut out his heart?

The rule that whoever stabbed Davy Jones' heart would take on his mantle allowed Will's life to be saved, but only if he cut out his heart and stored it away in a chest— something that was never meant to be a requirement.

Why did Will have to stab the heart?

However, in At Worlds End, after Davey Jones is vanquished and Will Turner is dying or dead, Will's heart is cut out so that he can become captain of the Flying Dutchman and take on Davey Jones' former role as psychopomp.

Why did Jack Sparrow want the heart?

Jack Sparrow races to recover the heart of Davy Jones to avoid enslaving his soul to Jones' service, as other friends and foes seek the heart for their own agenda as well.

What happens if Davy Jones stabs his own heart?

The person who stabs the heart must be the captain, and so if he stabs his own heart, there would be no captain.

Salazar's Revenge - Best Scene

Why can't Elizabeth stay on the Flying Dutchman?

Why couldn't Elizabeth Swann stay with William Turner when he became the captain of Flying Dutchman? Its not an option for anyone to stay in The flying Dutchman. One has to sell one's soul to live in the flying Dutchman or one has to be dead.

Why did Jack push will off the ship?

As Jack secretly negotiates his freedom with Beckett, Elizabeth is handed over to Feng, who believes she is Calypso, while the rest of the crew make for Shipwreck Cove aboard the Pearl. Jack throws Will off the ship as part of a plan to seize control of the Dutchman.

Who does Jack Sparrow really love?

Despite all the aforementioned characters being Jack's old flames, Angelica is the only one that particularly received the status of a true love interest.

What is Jack Sparrow's true desire?

Well, what Jack wants most is freedom. However, since he's had the compass for a long time, he knows how to use it to find other things he desires such as the Fountain of Youth in the forth film. In the fifth film we see him look at it and it point to the ocean, before he trades it for rum.

Why can't Jack use the compass?

Why doesn't your compass work?" Seeking help from the mystic Tia Dalma, she asked Jack on why he couldn't have just used the compass to lead him to the key. She then realized that either Jack didn't know what he wanted or he knew but are loath to claim it as his own.

Why did Davy Jones betray Calypso?

However, when Jones returned to shore after ten years, Calypso failed to appear. Believing Calypso had betrayed him, a heartbroken and enraged Davy Jones turned the Pirate Brethren against her, saying that if she were removed from the world, they would be able to claim the seas for themselves.

How is Will Turner alive without his heart?

He has it back inside him.

Jack used the hand of the unconscious Will to impale Jones' heart with his broken sword. This act not only defeated Jones, but gave Will eternal life by making him the new captain of the Flying Dutchman. Will's father cut out his son's heart and placed it in the Dead Man's Chest.

Why did Jack owe Davy Jones?

Jack Sparrows debt of 100 souls to Davy Jones is because he freed 100 slaves. Freeing the slaves cost him his ship in getting the ship back he must repay the cost of the hundred slaves with 100 souls. But how does all this cast Sparrow differently?

Why did Will Turner betray Jack?

Will Turner seems to betray Jack on every occasion he can. In Dead Man's Chest, he ends up hunting Jack to save Elizabeth from being sentenced to death, all to give the compass to Lord Beckett.

Why did Davy Jones turn into a squid?

4. How did Davy Jones become a squid? After Calypso's betrayal, Davy Jones carved his heart and locked it in the Dead Man's Chest. He abandoned his duty and turned into an ugly monster with an octopus-like face, tentacle beard, and crab legs and hands.

What curse does Will Turner have?

The last time audiences saw him, Will was the new captain of the Flying Dutchman and was therefore cursed to only return to land every 10 years.

What is Jack Sparrow's curse?

His most powerful curse, the Black Spot, infuses his arm in uncontrollable cursed magic, but Captain Jack Sparrow was never one to let such a thing hold him back. After all, no self-respecting swashbuckler leaves the cabin without their captain's hat, pirate coat, and…

What is Jack Sparrow's most famous quote?

Why is Jack Sparrow immortal?

Right before the film's climactic battle with the pirates at Isla de Muerta, Sparrow swipes a cursed coin from the treasure chest, making himself immortal and capable of dueling Barbossa. He shoots his nemesis with the pistol he has carried for ten years just as Will breaks the curse, killing Barbossa.

Does Jack Sparrow ever meet his daughter?

Captain Jack Sparrow has a daughter. Birdie Sparrow has never met her father and her mother is dead, so she seeks to find her father. When she finally finds him, she can't te him the thruth instead works as part of the crew on his ship.

Who betrayed Jack Sparrow?

Three days into the voyage, the first mate of the Pearl, Hector Barbossa, tricked Captain Jack Sparrow into giving up the bearings to Isla de Muerta. That night, mutineers led by Barbossa overtook the Black Pearl and marooned their former captain to die on a deserted island.

Was Will mad at Elizabeth for kissing Jack?

Despite Will witnessing Elizabeth kissing Jack and believing that she was in love with him, Will approaches Elizabeth to save Jack from the Davy Jones' locker. He mistakes her guilt as grief, but he puts her feelings first. To him, it's Elizabeth's happiness that is the most important.

Why did Calypso turn into crabs?

As a heathen goddess, Calypso was able to take many forms. But since the crab was attributed as her symbol, most notably by pirates, she chose that form. When Tia Dalma was transformed back into Calypso, she grew to ten times her normal size and crashed to the deck of the Black Pearl as thousands of little crabs.

Does Barbossa hate Jack?

Actually, they earnestly liked each other in The Price of Freedom and in the book series Jack saw Barbossa as his friend and his loyal follower, even if he mocked him very often (for his big hat, his vanity, him being the pirate lord of the Caspian Sea).

Why did Jack send will to the Flying Dutchman?

Upon finding a damaged ship, Jack sends Will aboard to "settle" his debt with Jones. Will is captured by the fish-like crewmen of the Flying Dutchman and Davy Jones reunites with Jack, forcing him to gather one-hundred souls in three days for his deal to be called off.