JK Rowling responded to the theories with "She has an affinity for this horrible object, which would help rather than hinder her." So, the horcrux certainly would add to her existing evil. But Umbridge is just that: plain evil. And as for the horcrux: Ron took care of that.
If anything the Locket may have been channeling her anti-muggle hatred and expanding on it. Dolores Umbridge complemented Voldemort's essence well so there really was no negative effect just an expansion on how Umbridge already acted.
Her prejudiced views toward Muggles were so vile that even Ministry workers with anti-muggle ideologies were shocked by her suggestions of how the non-magical community should be treated. Despised her Muggle mother and her Squib brother, considering them inferior to her and her father under the latter's influence.
She is corrupt. Rather than shutting Mundungus Fletcher's illegal business down, Umbridge took his goods as a bribe – one of which was Slytherin's locket. I'd like to argue that since she wore the locket (being Voldemort's Horcrux) and didn't seem any different, she wasn't hindered by the Dark object.
Yes, but Voldemort is convinced that no one knows he made Horcruxes. And that the Horcrux is safe in the cave. Besides, he would never allow anyone to wear the Slytherin locket. She kept lying to everyone that it was a family heirloom and that she was related to the Slelwyns.
Was Umbridge a terrible person because of the horcrux?
Was Dolores evil because of the Horcrux?
JK Rowling responded to the theories with "She has an affinity for this horrible object, which would help rather than hinder her." So, the horcrux certainly would add to her existing evil. But Umbridge is just that: plain evil. And as for the horcrux: Ron took care of that.
Although Umbridge was not a Death Eater, and had no direct contact with Lord Voldemort, she showed that she was fairly in line with their goals. This was due to Umbridge's callous nature and her prejudiced beliefs, both of which were similar to Death Eater behavior.
In turn, Umbridge acts in the open, from a position of power, being the Minister of Magic's right hand. She's not a Death Eater masquerading as a government official — she's just an awful person taking advantage of being in a top position.
Hermione Didn't Have a Weakness That the Horcrux Could Exploit. Ron doubted Harry for embarking on a mission with little to no information. Harry was angry and disappointed in Dumbledore for keeping secrets. Hermione prioritized the mission above everything.
Well, in Umbridge's case, while she may have been working for the bad guys of bureaucracy, she was never under Voldemort's thumb. She was allied with the Death Eaters and definitely enabled them, she was never an official part of the organization.
Bellatrix was an unapologetic monster who utterly relished in the pain and torment she caused, Umbridge was a monster but a monster in a pink coat, she could hide her evil behind a fake smile and supposed civility.
That's why Umbridge is so much more hateable; Voldemort ignores the rules to destroy people, Umbridge rewrites them to do it. This. Umbridge is the kind of evil that gets away with it - either because they wrote the rules and enforce them themselves or because they've got the person who does in their pocket.
The only staff member who supported Umbridge whole-heartedly was the caretaker, Argus Filch, who grew to like her methods, as well as being given permission to torture students himself. She later fired Gamekeeper Rubeus Hagrid, as he was a half-giant.
What happened to Umbridge after the Centaurs took her?
Umbridge was ultimately rescued by Dumbledore, although she was apparently left with a significant fear of centaurs afterwards, reacting violently at even the sound of hoof-beats.
Why wasn't Dolores Umbridge ever afraid of Albus Dumbledore? Because, being a complete nut-case, she falsely believed Dumbledore could never hurt her. > “The Chair recognizes Dolores Jane Umbridge, Senior Undersecretary to the Minister,” said (Cornelius) Fudge.
In July 1997, Moody was killed by Lord Voldemort during the Battle of the Seven Potters. Moody's corpse was recovered by the Death Eaters, and his magical eye was somehow taken by Dolores Umbridge, who used it to keep track of her subordinates in the British Ministry of Magic.
Why didn't Bellatrix make a horcrux? - Quora. Because her life goal was just to please the dark lord. Not immortality, but to live out her life committed to Voldemort, doing whatever he says. Of course, there is also a possibility that she didn't know about horcruxes.
But Harry didn't die, and the reason is rather simple: when Voldemort cast the killing curse, it only killed the piece of his soul within Harry, not Harry himself. Harry then saw Dumbledore in a version of King's Cross station, something that Dumbledore said was probably happening in his head.
Why didn't Harry use Avada Kedavra on the Horcruxes?
To Harry, Voldemort was the epitome of evil, as was the Killing Curse by extension, so he would not use the Unforgivable Curse that killed his parents. It's also believed that Avada Kedavra requires the caster to be willing to commit murder for the spell to work.
This is what makes Umbridge's evil more sinister than Voldemort's; it is far more real, much like that which Kesey depicts through Nurse Ratched, who torments and dominates the patients in her care (and eventually sees one lobotomized).
Correctly judged, by senior Death Eaters, to have much more in common with them than she ever had with Albus Dumbledore, she not only retained her post but was given extra authority, becoming Head of the Muggle-born Registration Commission, which was in effect a kangaroo court that imprisoned all Muggle-borns on the ...
Peter Pettigrew (a.k.a. Wormtail) is one of two Death Eaters known to have been in a House other than Slytherin (Gryffindor) while at Hogwarts. There, he was a close friend of Sirius Black, James Potter, and Remus Lupin, although he was the least intelligent and least talented of the group.
Why did Harry's scar hurt when Umbridge touched him?
J. K. Rowling stated that the pain from Harry's scar on his forehead was caused by the piece of Voldemort's soul trying to leave his body through the wound it entered to rejoin its master's soul.
As Dolores Umbridge was a sadist who enjoyed torturing students, Filch could relate to this. Also, as Umbridge granted Filch permission to torture misbehaving students, whereas Dumbledore would never even think of such things, he had loyalty to her. He is the only person who liked her at the school.
In keeping with his dislike for students and their inevitable tendency to create messes and disorder (which he, as caretaker, would get stuck cleaning up), Filch idolised "the old ways" of discipline and constantly lamented that he was no longer allowed to use corporal punishment.
