James is destined to die, as Voldemort never gives him an option to save himself. On the other hand, Lily has the choice to step aside — most likely because Snape had requested Voldemort to spare her life, in exchange for details about the prophecy.

Why did Dumbledore not protect Lily and James?

He hid them using the only thing that would work against Voldemort. He used Fidelius charm and after that even secret keeper was to be protected using that as Sirius said in PoA. The plan failed because wormtail who was their secret keeper betrayed them.

Why weren t james and lily each others secret keepers?

Others have theorized that there was a certain level of danger in Lily or James being their own Secret Keepers, as it was possible to accidentally bring people into the charm's protection.

Why did Lily hate James?

One with a severe dislike of Lily's former best friend. Let's get into your points one by one, though I would like to say first that I'm not sure if that quote from Lily about James making her sick really matches up with her being the 'submissive one'. - Yes, Lily knows James is a bully. That is why she loathed him.

Why didn't Lily and James fight Voldemort?

Because they trusted wormtail, they didn't expect Voldemort to blast their door down. At the moment that he did they were having a bit of fun as a family, and both Lily and James had put their wands down. They didn't have a chance to pick their wands up before they died, so couldn't have put up a fight at all.

Why James Potter's Loving Sacrifice Didn't Protect Lily from Voldemort - Harry Potter Theory

Was Lily pregnant when Voldemort killed her?

J.K. Rowling apparently confirmed that Lily Potter was pregnant again when Voldemort murdered her | Fandom. Thus, in murdering the Potters, save for Harry, Voldemort also killed a younger brother or sister that Harry would ultimately never know before it was even born.

Why didn't James sacrifice work?

Although James Potter definitely sacrificed his life trying to keep his family safe, the key here is that he wasn't given a choice to live, unlike what happened with Lily, and having the option to live but the victim consciously and willingly choosing death is what makes sacrificial protection happen.

Why did Lily choose James over Snape?

Originally Answered: In the Harry Potter series, why didn't Lily marry Snape? The simple answer: She didn't love him. The more complicated answer: He proved again and again that he wasn't willing to listen to Lily, respect her or her views, or love her in a healthy way.

Did Lily choose James over Snape?

Obviously Lily ultimately chose James Potter over Severus Snape, and Lily and James got married and had their only child, Harry Potter. But Lily could have just as easily made another choice, and despite some of Snape's more obvious negative qualities she certainly did have strong feelings for him as well.

Did James really take off Snape's pants?

It is not implied that he removed them although it is a possibility. I have skimmed Snape's Worst Memory countless times to prove to people that Snape was the aggressor and that he attacked James with Sectumsempra when his back was turned.

Did Lily know James was an Animagus?

It is unknown if Lily Evans knew it, but as she married James Potter, it is likely she did.

Why was Remus not a secret keeper?

First Wizarding War

Originally meant to be the Secret Keeper for James and Lily Potter, Sirius Black thought Voldemort was on to him (he thought that Remus Lupin was a spy). He therefore passed on the role of Secret Keeper to Peter Pettigrew.

Why did they think Sirius was bad?

Sirius Black is introduced in the third Harry Potter installment as the Prisoner of Azkaban, a dark and menacing figure feared by the Wizarding World almost as much as Voldemort himself. Everyone believes he's a mass murderer who betrayed Harry Potter's parents to the Dark Side.

Why did Harry's dad bully Snape?

James isn't motivated by anything much in attacking Snape in this way; he does it because he's bored, because he can, and because he wants to show off to some admiring girls, including Harry's mother, Lily. Harry is deeply disturbed by witnessing Snape's worst memory.

How did Snape convince Voldemort to spare Lily?

He begged Voldemort to spare her, who agreed. However, knowing that he could not leave Lily's safety in the hands of someone who could turn back at his word on a mere whim and that Lily would probably defend her child to the last breath, Snape also approached Albus Dumbledore to ask him to save Lily.

Why did Snape join Voldemort if he loved Lily?

Snape's strained relationship with Lily, who chose James and allowed him and his clique to bully Snape, further pushed him towards the Death Eaters. Despite his love for Lily, the pain from his adolescence couldn't erase the trauma. Snape's redemption came when Lily was murdered by Voldemort.

Who loved Lily more James or Snape?

James Potter loved Lily more. James Potter and Severus Snape are very different and yet very similar. James was born to a wealthy inventor, Fleamont Potter, and his loving wife.

How did Snape feel when Lily married James?

Though Snape and Lily were only friends, Snape was in love with Lily and couldn't move on because of his guilt. Through his memories, it's revealed that he was worried about Harry's future when Lily and James died and that he was afraid of seeing Harry when he was old enough to attend Hogwarts.

Did Lily ever forgive Snape?

She missed Snape, but she knew she could never forgive him. Snape never stopped trying to make amends. But Lily remained steadfast. She could not, would not, forgive him.

What was Snape's Patronus before Lily died?

A doe. And in his final battle with Lord Voldemort, Harry explained the significance of this to his adversary, and to us: 'Snape's Patronus was a doe,' said Harry, 'the same as my mother's, because he loved her for nearly all of his life, from the time when they were children'.

What did Snape call Lily?

In the heat of the moment, Snape lost control and called Lily the forbidden word. He called her a mud-blood by accident because he was frustrated that lily did not like his closest friends. He did not mean it.

Did James call Lily a mudblood?

He Called Lily A Mudblood

That's right, Snape called Lily a mudblood, the worst possible thing you can call a witch with muggle parents. Granted, Snape said it in the heat of the moment while fighting against James and his entire group of Marauders, but there are no takebacks from something like that.

Why did Lily's sacrifice save Harry?

On the other hand, Lily was offered the chance to step aside because Voldemort had promised Severus Snape that he wouldn't kill her unless she got in his way. Her conscious refusal to comply with Voldemort's demand was why unusually strong magical protection was conferred upon her son.

Why did Lily's sacrifice protect Harry?

Lily's Sacrifice Protected Harry In Several Different Ways

Dumbledore understood immediately that, so long as Harry resided with someone who shared Lily's blood, Voldemort would continue to be unable to harm him. This is why the headmaster placed Harry with Petunia Dursley.

Did Voldemort try to recruit Lily Potter?

Lily and James were recruited to become Death Eaters

But the author also told The Leaky Cauldron's "PotterCast" podcast in 2007 that Voldemort tried to recruit Muggle-born Lily Potter, along with James, to join the group.